From: garciadeblas <gerardo.garciadeblas@telefonica.com>
Date: Thu, 5 Sep 2019 14:36:06 +0000 (+0200)
Subject: Support of multiple VCA instances and a platform-independent API in N2VC
X-Git-Url: https://osm.etsi.org/gitweb/?a=commitdiff_plain;h=2cd229ac8a60ec9e40962e782f7a580070043d0e;p=osm%2FFeatures.git

Support of multiple VCA instances and a platform-independent API in N2VC

Change-Id: I1c3fb64abd2eb22946fc903e674915fdfe30e11b
Signed-off-by: garciadeblas <gerardo.garciadeblas@telefonica.com>
---

diff --git a/Support_of_multiple_VCA_instances_and_a_platform-independent_API_in_N2VC.md b/Support_of_multiple_VCA_instances_and_a_platform-independent_API_in_N2VC.md
new file mode 100644
index 0000000..0f83787
--- /dev/null
+++ b/Support_of_multiple_VCA_instances_and_a_platform-independent_API_in_N2VC.md
@@ -0,0 +1,66 @@
+# Support of multiple VCA instances and a platform-independent API in N2VC
+
+## Proposers
+
+- Gerardo Garcia (Telefonica)
+- Alfonso Tierno (Telefonica)
+- Francisco Javier Ramon (Telefonica)
+- Adam Israel (Canonical)
+- José Antonio Quiles (Indra)
+
+## Type
+
+Feature
+
+## Target MDG/TF
+
+N2VC, LCM
+
+## Description
+
+Currently, OSM assumes that management networks of all the VNF instances are remotely accessible
+by OSM from outside the datacenter, either directly or via floating IPs, so that VCA can drive
+successfully its operations with the VNFs. While this way of work has many advantages in telco
+clouds it might be somewhat rigid in hybrid deployments where e.g. public clouds are involved. In
+fact, this imposes some networking conditions to OSM so that VCA can access to all the
+management networks of each target VIM.
+
+In addition, the current N2VC library is platform-dependent. Most of the API calls are juju-specific
+instead of providing a higher level interface.
+
+While this shouldn't be an issue from the point of view of the actual behaviour of the OSM platform
+as a whole, it has three main drawbacks:
+
+- Architecturally speaking, it breaks the general principles of abstraction and layering, percolating
+  terminology and way of thinking northbound.
+- It complicates the implementation of features in LCM, since LCM needs to understand all the internals
+  of each call and figure out the actual state of N2VC and VCA internals.
+- It locks the workflow in LCM, which cannot be modified without changing N2VC. As a result, almost
+  every new feature impacting N2VC (support of native charms, secure key management, support of
+  relations, NS primitives) forces to change in the workflow in LCM, as current workflows are entirely
+  VCA-oriented (rather than LCM-oriented) due to the aforementioned problem in layering.
+
+This feature is intended to re-define the N2VC API to restore the layering, make it truly
+platform-independent (agnostic of the VCA terminology), and able to support multiple VCA instances.
+It will require the implementation of a generic class in N2VC, defining those API calls and the
+expected behaviour.
+
+The main premises of the new N2VC API would be the following:
+
+- **High-level abstraction API.** The current platform-dependent objects managed by N2VC (machines,
+  charms, models, applications) will be replaced by a new set of generic platform-independent objects
+  (execution environment, configuration SW, namespaces).
+- Keep a decoupling among the elements to be configured, the configuration SW and the execution
+  environment, so that the workflows in current VCA can be reproduced.
+- **API calls should be defined in such a way that allows to do things in parallel.** For instance, it
+  is not necessary to wait for the RO to finish the instantiation to before makeing VCA to create the
+  execution environments, or vice-versa.
+- **Layering and isolation.** LCM workflow (sequence of N2VC calls) could change in the future and it
+  should not impact N2VC or vice-versa.
+- **Transparency in progress of operation and states.** N2VC should be able to update directly the Mongo
+  records associated to the operation in progress.
+
+## Demo or definition of done
+
+All DEVOPS tests using VNF/NS packages with charms should work in the same way as they are working today.
+