Extracts individual validations for VnfdTopic and NsdTopic classes and adds unit... 95/9895/5
authorgarciaale <agarcia@whitestack.com>
Tue, 20 Oct 2020 21:29:45 +0000 (18:29 -0300)
committertierno <alfonso.tiernosepulveda@telefonica.com>
Mon, 16 Nov 2020 08:46:25 +0000 (09:46 +0100)
Change-Id: I4eada3cc7207b583f1d47f5fa2cf982152c811e6
Signed-off-by: garciaale <agarcia@whitestack.com>
osm_nbi/descriptor_topics.py
osm_nbi/tests/test_descriptor_topics.py

index 24f47a9..3bdaa03 100644 (file)
@@ -62,6 +62,7 @@ class DescriptorTopic(BaseTopic):
                                                           .format(desc_item_id, list_item[desc_item_id],
                                                                   position), HTTPStatus.UNPROCESSABLE_ENTITY)
                                 used_ids.append(list_item[desc_item_id])
+
         _check_unique_id_name(final_content)
         # 1. validate again with pyangbind
         # 1.1. remove internal keys
@@ -238,9 +239,9 @@ class DescriptorTopic(BaseTopic):
                         break
                     file_pkg.write(indata_text)
             if content_range_text:
-                if indata_len != end-start:
+                if indata_len != end - start:
                     raise EngineException("Mismatch between Content-Range header {}-{} and body length of {}".format(
-                        start, end-1, indata_len), HTTPStatus.REQUESTED_RANGE_NOT_SATISFIABLE)
+                        start, end - 1, indata_len), HTTPStatus.REQUESTED_RANGE_NOT_SATISFIABLE)
                 if end != total:
                     # TODO update to UPLOADING
                     return False
@@ -361,7 +362,7 @@ class DescriptorTopic(BaseTopic):
                                   "onboardingState is {}".format(content["_admin"]["onboardingState"]),
                                   http_code=HTTPStatus.CONFLICT)
         storage = content["_admin"]["storage"]
-        if path is not None and path != "$DESCRIPTOR":   # artifacts
+        if path is not None and path != "$DESCRIPTOR":  # artifacts
             if not storage.get('pkg-dir'):
                 raise EngineException("Packages does not contains artifacts", http_code=HTTPStatus.BAD_REQUEST)
             if self.fs.file_exists((storage['folder'], storage['pkg-dir'], *path), 'dir'):
@@ -369,7 +370,7 @@ class DescriptorTopic(BaseTopic):
                 return folder_content, "text/plain"
                 # TODO manage folders in http
             else:
-                return self.fs.file_open((storage['folder'], storage['pkg-dir'], *path), "rb"),\
+                return self.fs.file_open((storage['folder'], storage['pkg-dir'], *path), "rb"), \
                     "application/octet-stream"
 
         # pkgtype   accept  ZIP  TEXT    -> result
@@ -448,7 +449,7 @@ class DescriptorTopic(BaseTopic):
                 raise EngineException("userDefinedData should be an object, but is '{}' instead"
                                       .format(type(data)),
                                       http_code=HTTPStatus.BAD_REQUEST)
-        
+
         if ("operationalState" in indata["_admin"] and
                 content["_admin"]["operationalState"] == indata["_admin"]["operationalState"]):
             raise EngineException("operationalState already {}".format(content["_admin"]["operationalState"]),
@@ -540,86 +541,128 @@ class VnfdTopic(DescriptorTopic):
 
         indata = self.pyangbind_validation("vnfds", indata, force)
         # Cross references validation in the descriptor
-        if indata.get("vdu"):
-            if not indata.get("mgmt-interface"):
-                raise EngineException("'mgmt-interface' is a mandatory field and it is not defined",
+        self.validate_mgmt_interfaces_connection_points(indata)
+
+        for vdu in get_iterable(indata.get("vdu")):
+            self.validate_vdu_connection_point_refs(vdu, indata)
+            self._validate_vdu_charms_in_package(storage_params, vdu, indata)
+            self._validate_vdu_cloud_init_in_package(storage_params, vdu, indata)
+
+        self._validate_vnf_charms_in_package(storage_params, indata)
+
+        self.validate_internal_vlds(indata)
+        self.validate_monitoring_params(indata)
+        self.validate_scaling_group_descriptor(indata)
+
+        return indata
+
+    @staticmethod
+    def validate_mgmt_interfaces_connection_points(indata):
+        if not indata.get("vdu"):
+            return
+        if not indata.get("mgmt-interface"):
+            raise EngineException("'mgmt-interface' is a mandatory field and it is not defined",
+                                  http_code=HTTPStatus.UNPROCESSABLE_ENTITY)
+        if indata["mgmt-interface"].get("cp"):
+            for cp in get_iterable(indata.get("connection-point")):
+                if cp["name"] == indata["mgmt-interface"]["cp"]:
+                    break
+            else:
+                raise EngineException("mgmt-interface:cp='{}' must match an existing connection-point"
+                                      .format(indata["mgmt-interface"]["cp"]),
                                       http_code=HTTPStatus.UNPROCESSABLE_ENTITY)
-            if indata["mgmt-interface"].get("cp"):
+
+    @staticmethod
+    def validate_vdu_connection_point_refs(vdu, indata):
+        icp_refs = []
+        ecp_refs = []
+        for interface in get_iterable(vdu.get("interface")):
+            if interface.get("external-connection-point-ref"):
+                if interface.get("external-connection-point-ref") in ecp_refs:
+                    raise EngineException("vdu[id='{}']:interface[name='{}']:external-connection-point-ref='{}' "
+                                          "is referenced by other interface"
+                                          .format(vdu["id"], interface["name"],
+                                                  interface["external-connection-point-ref"]),
+                                          http_code=HTTPStatus.UNPROCESSABLE_ENTITY)
+                ecp_refs.append(interface.get("external-connection-point-ref"))
                 for cp in get_iterable(indata.get("connection-point")):
-                    if cp["name"] == indata["mgmt-interface"]["cp"]:
+                    if cp["name"] == interface["external-connection-point-ref"]:
                         break
                 else:
-                    raise EngineException("mgmt-interface:cp='{}' must match an existing connection-point"
-                                          .format(indata["mgmt-interface"]["cp"]),
+                    raise EngineException("vdu[id='{}']:interface[name='{}']:external-connection-point-ref='{}' "
+                                          "must match an existing connection-point"
+                                          .format(vdu["id"], interface["name"],
+                                                  interface["external-connection-point-ref"]),
+                                          http_code=HTTPStatus.UNPROCESSABLE_ENTITY)
+            elif interface.get("internal-connection-point-ref"):
+                if interface.get("internal-connection-point-ref") in icp_refs:
+                    raise EngineException("vdu[id='{}']:interface[name='{}']:internal-connection-point-ref='{}' "
+                                          "is referenced by other interface"
+                                          .format(vdu["id"], interface["name"],
+                                                  interface["internal-connection-point-ref"]),
+                                          http_code=HTTPStatus.UNPROCESSABLE_ENTITY)
+                icp_refs.append(interface.get("internal-connection-point-ref"))
+                for internal_cp in get_iterable(vdu.get("internal-connection-point")):
+                    if interface["internal-connection-point-ref"] == internal_cp.get("id"):
+                        break
+                else:
+                    raise EngineException("vdu[id='{}']:interface[name='{}']:internal-connection-point-ref='{}' "
+                                          "must match an existing vdu:internal-connection-point"
+                                          .format(vdu["id"], interface["name"],
+                                                  interface["internal-connection-point-ref"]),
                                           http_code=HTTPStatus.UNPROCESSABLE_ENTITY)
 
-        for vdu in get_iterable(indata.get("vdu")):
-            icp_refs = []
-            ecp_refs = []
-            for interface in get_iterable(vdu.get("interface")):
-                if interface.get("external-connection-point-ref"):
-                    if interface.get("external-connection-point-ref") in ecp_refs:
-                        raise EngineException("vdu[id='{}']:interface[name='{}']:external-connection-point-ref='{}' "
-                                              "is referenced by other interface"
-                                              .format(vdu["id"], interface["name"],
-                                                      interface["external-connection-point-ref"]),
-                                              http_code=HTTPStatus.UNPROCESSABLE_ENTITY)
-                    ecp_refs.append(interface.get("external-connection-point-ref"))
-                    for cp in get_iterable(indata.get("connection-point")):
-                        if cp["name"] == interface["external-connection-point-ref"]:
-                            break
-                    else:
-                        raise EngineException("vdu[id='{}']:interface[name='{}']:external-connection-point-ref='{}' "
-                                              "must match an existing connection-point"
-                                              .format(vdu["id"], interface["name"],
-                                                      interface["external-connection-point-ref"]),
-                                              http_code=HTTPStatus.UNPROCESSABLE_ENTITY)
-                elif interface.get("internal-connection-point-ref"):
-                    if interface.get("internal-connection-point-ref") in icp_refs:
-                        raise EngineException("vdu[id='{}']:interface[name='{}']:internal-connection-point-ref='{}' "
-                                              "is referenced by other interface"
-                                              .format(vdu["id"], interface["name"],
-                                                      interface["internal-connection-point-ref"]),
-                                              http_code=HTTPStatus.UNPROCESSABLE_ENTITY)
-                    icp_refs.append(interface.get("internal-connection-point-ref"))
-                    for internal_cp in get_iterable(vdu.get("internal-connection-point")):
-                        if interface["internal-connection-point-ref"] == internal_cp.get("id"):
-                            break
-                    else:
-                        raise EngineException("vdu[id='{}']:interface[name='{}']:internal-connection-point-ref='{}' "
-                                              "must match an existing vdu:internal-connection-point"
-                                              .format(vdu["id"], interface["name"],
-                                                      interface["internal-connection-point-ref"]),
-                                              http_code=HTTPStatus.UNPROCESSABLE_ENTITY)
-            # Validate that if descriptor contains charms, artifacts _admin.storage."pkg-dir" is not none
-            if vdu.get("vdu-configuration"):
-                if vdu["vdu-configuration"].get("juju"):
-                    if not self._validate_package_folders(storage_params, 'charms'):
-                        raise EngineException("Charm defined in vnf[id={}]:vdu[id={}] but not present in "
-                                              "package".format(indata["id"], vdu["id"]))
-            # Validate that if descriptor contains cloud-init, artifacts _admin.storage."pkg-dir" is not none
-            if vdu.get("cloud-init-file"):
-                if not self._validate_package_folders(storage_params, 'cloud_init', vdu["cloud-init-file"]):
-                    raise EngineException("Cloud-init defined in vnf[id={}]:vdu[id={}] but not present in "
-                                          "package".format(indata["id"], vdu["id"]))
-        # Validate that if descriptor contains charms, artifacts _admin.storage."pkg-dir" is not none
-        if indata.get("vnf-configuration"):
-            if indata["vnf-configuration"].get("juju"):
-                if not self._validate_package_folders(storage_params, 'charms'):
-                    raise EngineException("Charm defined in vnf[id={}] but not present in "
-                                          "package".format(indata["id"]))
+    def _validate_vdu_charms_in_package(self, storage_params, vdu, indata):
+        if not vdu.get("vdu-configuration"):
+            return
+        if vdu["vdu-configuration"].get("juju"):
+            if not self._validate_package_folders(storage_params, 'charms'):
+                raise EngineException("Charm defined in vnf[id={}]:vdu[id={}] but not present in "
+                                      "package".format(indata["id"], vdu["id"]))
+
+    def _validate_vdu_cloud_init_in_package(self, storage_params, vdu, indata):
+        if not vdu.get("cloud-init-file"):
+            return
+        if not self._validate_package_folders(storage_params, 'cloud_init', vdu["cloud-init-file"]):
+            raise EngineException("Cloud-init defined in vnf[id={}]:vdu[id={}] but not present in "
+                                  "package".format(indata["id"], vdu["id"]))
+
+    def _validate_vnf_charms_in_package(self, storage_params, indata):
+        if not indata.get("vnf-configuration"):
+            return
+        if indata["vnf-configuration"].get("juju"):
+            if not self._validate_package_folders(storage_params, 'charms'):
+                raise EngineException("Charm defined in vnf[id={}] but not present in "
+                                      "package".format(indata["id"]))
+
+    def _validate_package_folders(self, storage_params, folder, file=None):
+        if not storage_params or not storage_params.get("pkg-dir"):
+            return False
+        else:
+            if self.fs.file_exists("{}_".format(storage_params["folder"]), 'dir'):
+                f = "{}_/{}/{}".format(storage_params["folder"], storage_params["pkg-dir"], folder)
+            else:
+                f = "{}/{}/{}".format(storage_params["folder"], storage_params["pkg-dir"], folder)
+            if file:
+                return self.fs.file_exists("{}/{}".format(f, file), 'file')
+            else:
+                if self.fs.file_exists(f, 'dir'):
+                    if self.fs.dir_ls(f):
+                        return True
+            return False
+
+    @staticmethod
+    def validate_internal_vlds(indata):
         vld_names = []  # For detection of duplicated VLD names
         for ivld in get_iterable(indata.get("internal-vld")):
-            # BEGIN Detection of duplicated VLD names
             ivld_name = ivld.get("name")
-            if ivld_name:
-                if ivld_name in vld_names:
-                    raise EngineException("Duplicated VLD name '{}' in vnfd[id={}]:internal-vld[id={}]"
-                                          .format(ivld["name"], indata["id"], ivld["id"]),
-                                          http_code=HTTPStatus.UNPROCESSABLE_ENTITY)
-                else:
-                    vld_names.append(ivld_name)
-            # END Detection of duplicated VLD names
+            if ivld_name and ivld_name in vld_names:
+                raise EngineException("Duplicated VLD name '{}' in vnfd[id={}]:internal-vld[id={}]"
+                                      .format(ivld["name"], indata["id"], ivld["id"]),
+                                      http_code=HTTPStatus.UNPROCESSABLE_ENTITY)
+            else:
+                vld_names.append(ivld_name)
+
             for icp in get_iterable(ivld.get("internal-connection-point")):
                 icp_mark = False
                 for vdu in get_iterable(indata.get("vdu")):
@@ -641,12 +684,15 @@ class VnfdTopic(DescriptorTopic):
                     raise EngineException("internal-vld[id='{}']:ip-profile-ref='{}' does not exist".format(
                         ivld["id"], ivld["ip-profile-ref"]),
                         http_code=HTTPStatus.UNPROCESSABLE_ENTITY)
+
+    @staticmethod
+    def validate_monitoring_params(indata):
         for mp in get_iterable(indata.get("monitoring-param")):
             if mp.get("vdu-monitoring-param"):
                 mp_vmp_mark = False
                 for vdu in get_iterable(indata.get("vdu")):
                     for vmp in get_iterable(vdu.get("monitoring-param")):
-                        if vmp["id"] == mp["vdu-monitoring-param"].get("vdu-monitoring-param-ref") and vdu["id"] ==\
+                        if vmp["id"] == mp["vdu-monitoring-param"].get("vdu-monitoring-param-ref") and vdu["id"] == \
                                 mp["vdu-monitoring-param"]["vdu-ref"]:
                             mp_vmp_mark = True
                             break
@@ -676,6 +722,8 @@ class VnfdTopic(DescriptorTopic):
                                                   mp["vdu-metric"]["vdu-ref"]),
                                           http_code=HTTPStatus.UNPROCESSABLE_ENTITY)
 
+    @staticmethod
+    def validate_scaling_group_descriptor(indata):
         for sgd in get_iterable(indata.get("scaling-group-descriptor")):
             for sp in get_iterable(sgd.get("scaling-policy")):
                 for sc in get_iterable(sp.get("scaling-criteria")):
@@ -714,23 +762,6 @@ class VnfdTopic(DescriptorTopic):
                                           "vnf-configuration:config-primitive:name"
                                           .format(sgd["name"], sca["vnf-config-primitive-name-ref"]),
                                           http_code=HTTPStatus.UNPROCESSABLE_ENTITY)
-        return indata
-
-    def _validate_package_folders(self, storage_params, folder, file=None):
-        if not storage_params or not storage_params.get("pkg-dir"):
-            return False
-        else:
-            if self.fs.file_exists("{}_".format(storage_params["folder"]), 'dir'):
-                f = "{}_/{}/{}".format(storage_params["folder"], storage_params["pkg-dir"], folder)
-            else:
-                f = "{}/{}/{}".format(storage_params["folder"], storage_params["pkg-dir"], folder)
-            if file:
-                return self.fs.file_exists("{}/{}".format(f, file), 'file')
-            else:
-                if self.fs.file_exists(f, 'dir'):
-                    if self.fs.dir_ls(f):
-                        return True
-            return False
 
     def delete_extra(self, session, _id, db_content, not_send_msg=None):
         """
@@ -744,7 +775,7 @@ class VnfdTopic(DescriptorTopic):
         """
         super().delete_extra(session, _id, db_content, not_send_msg)
         self.db.del_list("vnfpkgops", {"vnfPkgId": _id})
-    
+
     def sol005_projection(self, data):
         data["onboardingState"] = data["_admin"]["onboardingState"]
         data["operationalState"] = data["_admin"]["operationalState"]
@@ -755,7 +786,7 @@ class VnfdTopic(DescriptorTopic):
         links["vnfd"] = {"href": "/vnfpkgm/v1/vnf_packages/{}/vnfd".format(data["_id"])}
         links["packageContent"] = {"href": "/vnfpkgm/v1/vnf_packages/{}/package_content".format(data["_id"])}
         data["_links"] = links
-    
+
         return super().sol005_projection(data)
 
 
@@ -797,41 +828,54 @@ class NsdTopic(DescriptorTopic):
         # Cross references validation in the descriptor
         # TODO validata that if contains cloud-init-file or charms, have artifacts _admin.storage."pkg-dir" is not none
         for vld in get_iterable(indata.get("vld")):
-            if vld.get("mgmt-network") and vld.get("ip-profile-ref"):
-                raise EngineException("Error at vld[id='{}']:ip-profile-ref"
-                                      " You cannot set an ip-profile when mgmt-network is True"
-                                      .format(vld["id"]), http_code=HTTPStatus.UNPROCESSABLE_ENTITY)
-            for vnfd_cp in get_iterable(vld.get("vnfd-connection-point-ref")):
-                for constituent_vnfd in get_iterable(indata.get("constituent-vnfd")):
-                    if vnfd_cp["member-vnf-index-ref"] == constituent_vnfd["member-vnf-index"]:
-                        if vnfd_cp.get("vnfd-id-ref") and vnfd_cp["vnfd-id-ref"] != constituent_vnfd["vnfd-id-ref"]:
-                            raise EngineException("Error at vld[id='{}']:vnfd-connection-point-ref[vnfd-id-ref='{}'] "
-                                                  "does not match constituent-vnfd[member-vnf-index='{}']:vnfd-id-ref"
-                                                  " '{}'".format(vld["id"], vnfd_cp["vnfd-id-ref"],
-                                                                 constituent_vnfd["member-vnf-index"],
-                                                                 constituent_vnfd["vnfd-id-ref"]),
-                                                  http_code=HTTPStatus.UNPROCESSABLE_ENTITY)
-                        break
-                else:
-                    raise EngineException("Error at vld[id='{}']:vnfd-connection-point-ref[member-vnf-index-ref='{}'] "
-                                          "does not match any constituent-vnfd:member-vnf-index"
-                                          .format(vld["id"], vnfd_cp["member-vnf-index-ref"]),
-                                          http_code=HTTPStatus.UNPROCESSABLE_ENTITY)
-        # Check VNFFGD
+            self.validate_vld_mgmt_network_with_ip_profile_ref(vld)
+            self.validate_vld_connection_point_refs(vld, indata)
+
         for fgd in get_iterable(indata.get("vnffgd")):
-            for cls in get_iterable(fgd.get("classifier")):
-                rspref = cls.get("rsp-id-ref")
-                for rsp in get_iterable(fgd.get("rsp")):
-                    rspid = rsp.get("id")
-                    if rspid and rspref and rspid == rspref:
-                        break
-                else:
-                    raise EngineException(
-                        "Error at vnffgd[id='{}']:classifier[id='{}']:rsp-id-ref '{}' does not match any rsp:id"
-                        .format(fgd["id"], cls["id"], rspref),
-                        http_code=HTTPStatus.UNPROCESSABLE_ENTITY)
+            self.validate_fgd_classifiers(fgd)
+
         return indata
 
+    @staticmethod
+    def validate_vld_mgmt_network_with_ip_profile_ref(vld):
+        if vld.get("mgmt-network") and vld.get("ip-profile-ref"):
+            raise EngineException("Error at vld[id='{}']:ip-profile-ref"
+                                  " You cannot set an ip-profile when mgmt-network is True"
+                                  .format(vld["id"]), http_code=HTTPStatus.UNPROCESSABLE_ENTITY)
+
+    @staticmethod
+    def validate_vld_connection_point_refs(vld, indata):
+        for vnfd_cp in get_iterable(vld.get("vnfd-connection-point-ref")):
+            for constituent_vnfd in get_iterable(indata.get("constituent-vnfd")):
+                if vnfd_cp["member-vnf-index-ref"] == constituent_vnfd["member-vnf-index"]:
+                    if vnfd_cp.get("vnfd-id-ref") and vnfd_cp["vnfd-id-ref"] != constituent_vnfd["vnfd-id-ref"]:
+                        raise EngineException("Error at vld[id='{}']:vnfd-connection-point-ref[vnfd-id-ref='{}'] "
+                                              "does not match constituent-vnfd[member-vnf-index='{}']:vnfd-id-ref"
+                                              " '{}'".format(vld["id"], vnfd_cp["vnfd-id-ref"],
+                                                             constituent_vnfd["member-vnf-index"],
+                                                             constituent_vnfd["vnfd-id-ref"]),
+                                              http_code=HTTPStatus.UNPROCESSABLE_ENTITY)
+                    break
+            else:
+                raise EngineException("Error at vld[id='{}']:vnfd-connection-point-ref[member-vnf-index-ref='{}'] "
+                                      "does not match any constituent-vnfd:member-vnf-index"
+                                      .format(vld["id"], vnfd_cp["member-vnf-index-ref"]),
+                                      http_code=HTTPStatus.UNPROCESSABLE_ENTITY)
+
+    @staticmethod
+    def validate_fgd_classifiers(fgd):
+        for cls in get_iterable(fgd.get("classifier")):
+            rspref = cls.get("rsp-id-ref")
+            for rsp in get_iterable(fgd.get("rsp")):
+                rspid = rsp.get("id")
+                if rspid and rspref and rspid == rspref:
+                    break
+            else:
+                raise EngineException(
+                    "Error at vnffgd[id='{}']:classifier[id='{}']:rsp-id-ref '{}' does not match any rsp:id"
+                    .format(fgd["id"], cls["id"], rspref),
+                    http_code=HTTPStatus.UNPROCESSABLE_ENTITY)
+
     def _validate_input_edit(self, indata, content, force=False):
         # not needed to validate with pyangbind becuase it will be validated at check_conflict_on_edit
         """
@@ -879,36 +923,42 @@ class NsdTopic(DescriptorTopic):
         """
         if session["force"]:
             return
+        member_vnfd_index = self._get_descriptor_constituent_vnfds_by_member_vnfd_index(session, descriptor)
+
+        # Cross references validation in the descriptor and vnfd connection point validation
+        for vld in get_iterable(descriptor.get("vld")):
+            self.validate_vld_connection_point_refs_vnfd_connection_points(vld, member_vnfd_index)
+
+    def _get_descriptor_constituent_vnfds_by_member_vnfd_index(self, session, descriptor):
         member_vnfd_index = {}
         if descriptor.get("constituent-vnfd") and not session["force"]:
             for vnf in descriptor["constituent-vnfd"]:
                 vnfd_id = vnf["vnfd-id-ref"]
-                filter_q = self._get_project_filter(session)
-                filter_q["id"] = vnfd_id
-                vnf_list = self.db.get_list("vnfds", filter_q)
+                query_filter = self._get_project_filter(session)
+                query_filter["id"] = vnfd_id
+                vnf_list = self.db.get_list("vnfds", query_filter)
                 if not vnf_list:
                     raise EngineException("Descriptor error at 'constituent-vnfd':'vnfd-id-ref'='{}' references a non "
                                           "existing vnfd".format(vnfd_id), http_code=HTTPStatus.CONFLICT)
-                # elif len(vnf_list) > 1:
-                #     raise EngineException("More than one vnfd found for id='{}'".format(vnfd_id),
-                #                           http_code=HTTPStatus.CONFLICT)
+
                 member_vnfd_index[vnf["member-vnf-index"]] = vnf_list[0]
+        return member_vnfd_index
 
-        # Cross references validation in the descriptor and vnfd connection point validation
-        for vld in get_iterable(descriptor.get("vld")):
-            for referenced_vnfd_cp in get_iterable(vld.get("vnfd-connection-point-ref")):
-                # look if this vnfd contains this connection point
-                vnfd = member_vnfd_index.get(referenced_vnfd_cp["member-vnf-index-ref"])
-                for vnfd_cp in get_iterable(vnfd.get("connection-point")):
-                    if referenced_vnfd_cp.get("vnfd-connection-point-ref") == vnfd_cp["name"]:
-                        break
-                else:
-                    raise EngineException(
-                        "Error at vld[id='{}']:vnfd-connection-point-ref[member-vnf-index-ref='{}']:vnfd-"
-                        "connection-point-ref='{}' references a non existing conection-point:name inside vnfd '{}'"
-                        .format(vld["id"], referenced_vnfd_cp["member-vnf-index-ref"],
-                                referenced_vnfd_cp["vnfd-connection-point-ref"], vnfd["id"]),
-                        http_code=HTTPStatus.UNPROCESSABLE_ENTITY)
+    @staticmethod
+    def validate_vld_connection_point_refs_vnfd_connection_points(vld, member_vnfd_index):
+        for referenced_vnfd_cp in get_iterable(vld.get("vnfd-connection-point-ref")):
+            # look if this vnfd contains this connection point
+            vnfd = member_vnfd_index.get(referenced_vnfd_cp["member-vnf-index-ref"])
+            for vnfd_cp in get_iterable(vnfd.get("connection-point")):
+                if referenced_vnfd_cp.get("vnfd-connection-point-ref") == vnfd_cp["name"]:
+                    break
+            else:
+                raise EngineException(
+                    "Error at vld[id='{}']:vnfd-connection-point-ref[member-vnf-index-ref='{}']:vnfd-"
+                    "connection-point-ref='{}' references a non existing conection-point:name inside vnfd '{}'"
+                    .format(vld["id"], referenced_vnfd_cp["member-vnf-index-ref"],
+                            referenced_vnfd_cp["vnfd-connection-point-ref"], vnfd["id"]),
+                    http_code=HTTPStatus.UNPROCESSABLE_ENTITY)
 
     def check_conflict_on_edit(self, session, final_content, edit_content, _id):
         super().check_conflict_on_edit(session, final_content, edit_content, _id)
@@ -943,7 +993,7 @@ class NsdTopic(DescriptorTopic):
         if self.db.get_list("nsts", _filter):
             raise EngineException("There is at least one NetSlice Template referencing this descriptor",
                                   http_code=HTTPStatus.CONFLICT)
-    
+
     def sol005_projection(self, data):
         data["nsdOnboardingState"] = data["_admin"]["onboardingState"]
         data["nsdOperationalState"] = data["_admin"]["operationalState"]
@@ -953,7 +1003,7 @@ class NsdTopic(DescriptorTopic):
         links["self"] = {"href": "/nsd/v1/ns_descriptors/{}".format(data["_id"])}
         links["nsd_content"] = {"href": "/nsd/v1/ns_descriptors/{}/nsd_content".format(data["_id"])}
         data["_links"] = links
-    
+
         return super().sol005_projection(data)
 
 
index 3853f76..5fbb337 100755 (executable)
@@ -32,7 +32,6 @@ from osm_nbi.engine import EngineException
 from osm_common.dbbase import DbException
 import yaml
 
-
 test_name = "test-user"
 db_vnfd_content = yaml.load(db_vnfds_text, Loader=yaml.Loader)[0]
 db_nsd_content = yaml.load(db_nsds_text, Loader=yaml.Loader)[0]
@@ -61,10 +60,10 @@ def compare_desc(tc, d1, d2, k):
     if isinstance(d1, dict) and isinstance(d2, dict):
         for key in d1.keys():
             if key in d2:
-                compare_desc(tc, d1[key], d2[key], k+"[{}]".format(key))
+                compare_desc(tc, d1[key], d2[key], k + "[{}]".format(key))
     elif isinstance(d1, list) and isinstance(d2, list) and len(d1) == len(d2):
         for i in range(len(d1)):
-            compare_desc(tc, d1[i], d2[i], k+"[{}]".format(i))
+            compare_desc(tc, d1[i], d2[i], k + "[{}]".format(i))
     else:
         tc.assertEqual(d1, d2, "Wrong descriptor content: {}".format(k))
 
@@ -147,7 +146,7 @@ class Test_VnfdTopic(TestCase):
             finally:
                 test_vnfd["vdu"][0]["cloud-init-file"] = tmp1
                 test_vnfd["vnf-configuration"]["juju"] = tmp2
-        self.db.get_one.side_effect = lambda table, filter, fail_on_empty=None, fail_on_more=None:\
+        self.db.get_one.side_effect = lambda table, filter, fail_on_empty=None, fail_on_more=None: \
             {"_id": did, "_admin": db_vnfd_content["_admin"]}
         with self.subTest(i=2, t='Check Pyangbind Validation: required properties'):
             tmp = test_vnfd["id"]
@@ -366,7 +365,7 @@ class Test_VnfdTopic(TestCase):
             sg["vdu"][0]["vdu-id-ref"] = test_vnfd["vdu"][0]["id"]
             sg["scaling-config-action"] = [{"trigger": "pre-scale-in"}]
             try:
-                with self.assertRaises(EngineException, msg="Accepted non-existent Scaling Group VDU ID Reference")\
+                with self.assertRaises(EngineException, msg="Accepted non-existent Scaling Group VDU ID Reference") \
                         as e:
                     self.topic.upload_content(fake_session, did, test_vnfd, {}, {"Content-Type": []})
                 self.assertEqual(e.exception.http_code, HTTPStatus.UNPROCESSABLE_ENTITY, "Wrong HTTP status code")
@@ -469,7 +468,7 @@ class Test_VnfdTopic(TestCase):
             self.db.set_one.assert_not_called()
             fs_del_calls = self.fs.file_delete.call_args_list
             self.assertEqual(fs_del_calls[0][0][0], did, "Wrong FS file id")
-            self.assertEqual(fs_del_calls[1][0][0], did+'_', "Wrong FS folder id")
+            self.assertEqual(fs_del_calls[1][0][0], did + '_', "Wrong FS folder id")
         with self.subTest(i=2, t='Conflict on Delete - VNFD in use by VNFR'):
             self.db.get_list.return_value = [{"_id": str(uuid4()), "name": "fake-vnfr"}]
             with self.assertRaises(EngineException, msg="Accepted VNFD in use by VNFR") as e:
@@ -516,6 +515,213 @@ class Test_VnfdTopic(TestCase):
             self.fs.file_delete.assert_not_called()
         return
 
+    def test_validate_mgmt_interfaces_connection_points_on_valid_descriptor(self):
+        indata = deepcopy(db_vnfd_content)
+        self.topic.validate_mgmt_interfaces_connection_points(indata)
+
+    def test_validate_mgmt_interfaces_connection_points_when_missing_connection_point(self):
+        indata = deepcopy(db_vnfd_content)
+        indata['connection-point'] = []
+        with self.assertRaises(EngineException) as e:
+            self.topic.validate_mgmt_interfaces_connection_points(indata)
+        self.assertEqual(e.exception.http_code, HTTPStatus.UNPROCESSABLE_ENTITY, "Wrong HTTP status code")
+        self.assertIn(norm("mgmt-interface:cp='{}' must match an existing connection-point"
+                           .format(indata["mgmt-interface"]["cp"])),
+                      norm(str(e.exception)), "Wrong exception text")
+
+    def test_validate_mgmt_interfaces_connection_points_when_missing_mgmt_interface(self):
+        indata = deepcopy(db_vnfd_content)
+        indata.pop('mgmt-interface')
+        with self.assertRaises(EngineException) as e:
+            self.topic.validate_mgmt_interfaces_connection_points(indata)
+        self.assertEqual(e.exception.http_code, HTTPStatus.UNPROCESSABLE_ENTITY, "Wrong HTTP status code")
+        self.assertIn(norm("'mgmt-interface' is a mandatory field and it is not defined"),
+                      norm(str(e.exception)), "Wrong exception text")
+
+    def test_validate_vdu_connection_point_refs_on_valid_descriptor(self):
+        indata = db_vnfd_content
+        vdu = indata['vdu'][0]
+        self.topic.validate_vdu_connection_point_refs(vdu, indata)
+
+    def test_validate_vdu_connection_point_refs_when_missing_internal_connection_point(self):
+        indata = deepcopy(db_vnfd_content)
+        vdu = indata['vdu'][0]
+        vdu.pop('internal-connection-point')
+        with self.assertRaises(EngineException) as e:
+            self.topic.validate_vdu_connection_point_refs(vdu, indata)
+        self.assertEqual(e.exception.http_code, HTTPStatus.UNPROCESSABLE_ENTITY, "Wrong HTTP status code")
+        self.assertIn(norm("vdu[id='{}']:interface[name='{}']:internal-connection-point-ref='{}' "
+                           "must match an existing vdu:internal-connection-point"
+                           .format(vdu["id"], vdu['interface'][1]["name"],
+                                   vdu['interface'][1]["internal-connection-point-ref"])),
+                      norm(str(e.exception)), "Wrong exception text")
+
+    def test_validate_vdu_connection_point_refs_when_missing_external_connection_point(self):
+        indata = deepcopy(db_vnfd_content)
+        vdu = indata['vdu'][0]
+        indata.pop('connection-point')
+        with self.assertRaises(EngineException) as e:
+            self.topic.validate_vdu_connection_point_refs(vdu, indata)
+        self.assertEqual(e.exception.http_code, HTTPStatus.UNPROCESSABLE_ENTITY, "Wrong HTTP status code")
+        self.assertIn(norm("vdu[id='{}']:interface[name='{}']:external-connection-point-ref='{}' "
+                           "must match an existing connection-point"
+                           .format(vdu["id"], vdu['interface'][0]["name"],
+                                   vdu['interface'][0]["external-connection-point-ref"])),
+                      norm(str(e.exception)), "Wrong exception text")
+
+    def test_validate_vdu_connection_point_refs_on_duplicated_internal_connection_point_ref(self):
+        indata = deepcopy(db_vnfd_content)
+        vdu = indata['vdu'][0]
+        duplicated_interface = {'name': 'dup-mgmt-eth1', 'position': 3,
+                                'internal-connection-point-ref': 'mgmtVM-internal'}
+        vdu['interface'].insert(0, duplicated_interface)
+        with self.assertRaises(EngineException) as e:
+            self.topic.validate_vdu_connection_point_refs(vdu, indata)
+        self.assertEqual(e.exception.http_code, HTTPStatus.UNPROCESSABLE_ENTITY, "Wrong HTTP status code")
+        self.assertIn(norm("vdu[id='{}']:interface[name='{}']:internal-connection-point-ref='{}' "
+                           "is referenced by other interface"
+                           .format(vdu["id"], vdu['interface'][2]["name"],
+                                   vdu['interface'][2]["internal-connection-point-ref"])),
+                      norm(str(e.exception)), "Wrong exception text")
+
+    def test_validate_vdu_connection_point_refs_on_duplicated_external_connection_point_ref(self):
+        indata = deepcopy(db_vnfd_content)
+        vdu = indata['vdu'][0]
+        duplicated_interface = {'name': 'dup-mgmt-eth0', 'position': 3, 'external-connection-point-ref': 'vnf-mgmt'}
+        vdu['interface'].insert(0, duplicated_interface)
+        with self.assertRaises(EngineException) as e:
+            self.topic.validate_vdu_connection_point_refs(vdu, indata)
+        self.assertEqual(e.exception.http_code, HTTPStatus.UNPROCESSABLE_ENTITY, "Wrong HTTP status code")
+        self.assertIn(norm("vdu[id='{}']:interface[name='{}']:external-connection-point-ref='{}' "
+                           "is referenced by other interface"
+                           .format(vdu["id"], vdu['interface'][1]["name"],
+                                   vdu['interface'][1]["external-connection-point-ref"])),
+                      norm(str(e.exception)), "Wrong exception text")
+
+    def test_validate_internal_vlds_on_valid_descriptor(self):
+        indata = db_vnfd_content
+        self.topic.validate_internal_vlds(indata)
+
+    def test_validate_internal_vlds_on_duplicated_vld(self):
+        indata = deepcopy(db_vnfd_content)
+        duplicated_vld = {'id': 'internal', 'name': 'internal',
+                          'internal-connection-point': [{'id-ref': 'mgmtVM-internal'}, {'id-ref': 'dataVM-internal'}]}
+        indata['internal-vld'].insert(0, duplicated_vld)
+        with self.assertRaises(EngineException) as e:
+            self.topic.validate_internal_vlds(indata)
+        self.assertEqual(e.exception.http_code, HTTPStatus.UNPROCESSABLE_ENTITY, "Wrong HTTP status code")
+        self.assertIn(norm("Duplicated VLD name '{}' in vnfd[id={}]:internal-vld[id={}]"
+                           .format(indata['internal-vld'][1]["name"], indata["id"], indata['internal-vld'][1]["id"])),
+                      norm(str(e.exception)), "Wrong exception text")
+
+    def test_validate_internal_vlds_when_missing_internal_connection_point(self):
+        indata = deepcopy(db_vnfd_content)
+        ivld = indata['internal-vld'][0]
+        icp = ivld['internal-connection-point'][0]
+        indata['vdu'][0]['internal-connection-point'].pop()
+        with self.assertRaises(EngineException) as e:
+            self.topic.validate_internal_vlds(indata)
+        self.assertEqual(e.exception.http_code, HTTPStatus.UNPROCESSABLE_ENTITY, "Wrong HTTP status code")
+        self.assertIn(norm("internal-vld[id='{}']:internal-connection-point='{}' must match an existing "
+                           "vdu:internal-connection-point".format(ivld["id"], icp["id-ref"])),
+                      norm(str(e.exception)), "Wrong exception text")
+
+    def test_validate_internal_vlds_when_missing_ip_profile(self):
+        indata = deepcopy(db_vnfd_content)
+        ivld = indata['internal-vld'][0]
+        ivld['ip-profile-ref'] = 'non-existing-ip-profile'
+        with self.assertRaises(EngineException) as e:
+            self.topic.validate_internal_vlds(indata)
+        self.assertEqual(e.exception.http_code, HTTPStatus.UNPROCESSABLE_ENTITY, "Wrong HTTP status code")
+        self.assertIn(norm("internal-vld[id='{}']:ip-profile-ref='{}' does not exist".format(
+            ivld["id"], ivld["ip-profile-ref"])),
+            norm(str(e.exception)), "Wrong exception text")
+
+    def test_validate_monitoring_params_on_valid_descriptor(self):
+        indata = db_vnfd_content
+        self.topic.validate_monitoring_params(indata)
+
+    def test_validate_monitoring_params_when_missing_vdu(self):
+        indata = deepcopy(db_vnfd_content)
+        monitoring_param = indata['monitoring-param'][0]
+        indata['vdu'].pop()
+        with self.assertRaises(EngineException) as e:
+            self.topic.validate_monitoring_params(indata)
+        self.assertEqual(e.exception.http_code, HTTPStatus.UNPROCESSABLE_ENTITY, "Wrong HTTP status code")
+        self.assertIn(norm("monitoring-param:vdu-monitoring-param:vdu-monitoring-param-ref='{}' not "
+                           "defined at vdu[id='{}'] or vdu does not exist"
+                           .format(monitoring_param["vdu-monitoring-param"]["vdu-monitoring-param-ref"],
+                                   monitoring_param["vdu-monitoring-param"]["vdu-ref"])),
+                      norm(str(e.exception)), "Wrong exception text")
+
+    def test_validate_monitoring_params_when_missing_vdu_monitoring_param_ref(self):
+        indata = deepcopy(db_vnfd_content)
+        monitoring_param = indata['monitoring-param'][0]
+        indata['vdu'][1]['monitoring-param'] = []
+        with self.assertRaises(EngineException) as e:
+            self.topic.validate_monitoring_params(indata)
+        self.assertEqual(e.exception.http_code, HTTPStatus.UNPROCESSABLE_ENTITY, "Wrong HTTP status code")
+        self.assertIn(norm("monitoring-param:vdu-monitoring-param:vdu-monitoring-param-ref='{}' not "
+                           "defined at vdu[id='{}'] or vdu does not exist"
+                           .format(monitoring_param["vdu-monitoring-param"]["vdu-monitoring-param-ref"],
+                                   monitoring_param["vdu-monitoring-param"]["vdu-ref"])),
+                      norm(str(e.exception)), "Wrong exception text")
+
+    def test_validate_scaling_group_descriptor_on_valid_descriptor(self):
+        indata = db_vnfd_content
+        self.topic.validate_scaling_group_descriptor(indata)
+
+    def test_validate_scaling_group_descriptor_when_missing_vnf_monitoring_param_ref(self):
+        indata = deepcopy(db_vnfd_content)
+        sgd = indata['scaling-group-descriptor'][0]
+        sc = sgd['scaling-policy'][0]['scaling-criteria'][0]
+        indata['monitoring-param'] = []
+        with self.assertRaises(EngineException) as e:
+            self.topic.validate_scaling_group_descriptor(indata)
+        self.assertEqual(e.exception.http_code, HTTPStatus.UNPROCESSABLE_ENTITY, "Wrong HTTP status code")
+        self.assertIn(norm("scaling-group-descriptor[name='{}']:scaling-criteria[name='{}']:"
+                           "vnf-monitoring-param-ref='{}' not defined in any monitoring-param"
+                           .format(sgd["name"], sc["name"], sc["vnf-monitoring-param-ref"])),
+                      norm(str(e.exception)), "Wrong exception text")
+
+    def test_validate_scaling_group_descriptor_when_missing_vdu(self):
+        indata = deepcopy(db_vnfd_content)
+        sgd = indata['scaling-group-descriptor'][0]
+        sgd_vdu = sgd['vdu'][0]
+        indata['vdu'].pop()
+        with self.assertRaises(EngineException) as e:
+            self.topic.validate_scaling_group_descriptor(indata)
+        self.assertEqual(e.exception.http_code, HTTPStatus.UNPROCESSABLE_ENTITY, "Wrong HTTP status code")
+        self.assertIn(norm("scaling-group-descriptor[name='{}']:vdu-id-ref={} does not match any vdu"
+                           .format(sgd["name"], sgd_vdu["vdu-id-ref"])),
+                      norm(str(e.exception)), "Wrong exception text")
+
+    def test_validate_scaling_group_descriptor_when_missing_vnf_configuration(self):
+        indata = deepcopy(db_vnfd_content)
+        sgd = indata['scaling-group-descriptor'][0]
+        indata.pop('vnf-configuration')
+        with self.assertRaises(EngineException) as e:
+            self.topic.validate_scaling_group_descriptor(indata)
+        self.assertEqual(e.exception.http_code, HTTPStatus.UNPROCESSABLE_ENTITY, "Wrong HTTP status code")
+        self.assertIn(norm("'vnf-configuration' not defined in the descriptor but it is referenced by "
+                           "scaling-group-descriptor[name='{}']:scaling-config-action"
+                           .format(sgd["name"])),
+                      norm(str(e.exception)), "Wrong exception text")
+
+    def test_validate_scaling_group_descriptor_when_missing_scaling_config_action_primitive(self):
+        indata = deepcopy(db_vnfd_content)
+        sgd = indata['scaling-group-descriptor'][0]
+        sca = sgd['scaling-config-action'][0]
+        indata['vnf-configuration']['config-primitive'] = []
+        with self.assertRaises(EngineException) as e:
+            self.topic.validate_scaling_group_descriptor(indata)
+        self.assertEqual(e.exception.http_code, HTTPStatus.UNPROCESSABLE_ENTITY, "Wrong HTTP status code")
+        self.assertIn(norm("scaling-group-descriptor[name='{}']:scaling-config-action:vnf-config-"
+                           "primitive-name-ref='{}' does not match any "
+                           "vnf-configuration:config-primitive:name"
+                           .format(sgd["name"], sca["vnf-config-primitive-name-ref"])),
+                      norm(str(e.exception)), "Wrong exception text")
+
 
 class Test_NsdTopic(TestCase):
 
@@ -590,7 +796,7 @@ class Test_NsdTopic(TestCase):
                 compare_desc(self, test_nsd, db_args[2], "NSD")
             finally:
                 pass
-        self.db.get_one.side_effect = lambda table, filter, fail_on_empty=None, fail_on_more=None:\
+        self.db.get_one.side_effect = lambda table, filter, fail_on_empty=None, fail_on_more=None: \
             {"_id": did, "_admin": db_nsd_content["_admin"]}
         with self.subTest(i=2, t='Check Pyangbind Validation: required properties'):
             tmp = test_nsd["id"]
@@ -716,19 +922,12 @@ class Test_NsdTopic(TestCase):
                                    .format(test_nsd["vld"][0]["id"],
                                            test_nsd["vld"][0]["vnfd-connection-point-ref"][0]["member-vnf-index-ref"],
                                            test_nsd["vld"][0]["vnfd-connection-point-ref"][0]
-                                                   ["vnfd-connection-point-ref"],
+                                           ["vnfd-connection-point-ref"],
                                            db_vnfd_content["id"])),
                               norm(str(e.exception)), "Wrong exception text")
             finally:
                 test_nsd["vld"][0]["vnfd-connection-point-ref"][0]["vnfd-connection-point-ref"] = tmp
         return
-        with self.subTest(i=11, t='Check Input Validation: everything right'):
-            test_nsd["id"] = "fake-nsd-id"
-            self.db.get_one.side_effect = [{"_id": did, "_admin": db_nsd_content["_admin"]}, None]
-            self.db.get_list.return_value = [db_vnfd_content]
-            rc = self.topic.upload_content(fake_session, did, test_nsd, {}, {"Content-Type": []})
-            self.assertTrue(rc, "Input Validation: Unexpected failure")
-        return
 
     def test_edit_nsd(self):
         did = db_nsd_content["_id"]
@@ -801,7 +1000,7 @@ class Test_NsdTopic(TestCase):
             self.db.set_one.assert_not_called()
             fs_del_calls = self.fs.file_delete.call_args_list
             self.assertEqual(fs_del_calls[0][0][0], did, "Wrong FS file id")
-            self.assertEqual(fs_del_calls[1][0][0], did+'_', "Wrong FS folder id")
+            self.assertEqual(fs_del_calls[1][0][0], did + '_', "Wrong FS folder id")
         with self.subTest(i=2, t='Conflict on Delete - NSD in use by nsr'):
             self.db.get_list.return_value = [{"_id": str(uuid4()), "name": "fake-nsr"}]
             with self.assertRaises(EngineException, msg="Accepted NSD in use by NSR") as e:
@@ -848,6 +1047,97 @@ class Test_NsdTopic(TestCase):
             self.fs.file_delete.assert_not_called()
         return
 
+    def test_validate_vld_mgmt_network_with_ip_profile_ref_on_valid_descriptor(self):
+        indata = deepcopy(db_nsd_content)
+        vld = indata['vld'][0]
+        self.topic.validate_vld_mgmt_network_with_ip_profile_ref(vld)
+
+    def test_validate_vld_mgmt_network_with_ip_profile_ref_when_both_defined(self):
+        indata = deepcopy(db_nsd_content)
+        vld = indata['vld'][0]
+        vld['ip-profile-ref'] = 'a-profile-ref'
+        with self.assertRaises(EngineException) as e:
+            self.topic.validate_vld_mgmt_network_with_ip_profile_ref(vld)
+        self.assertEqual(e.exception.http_code, HTTPStatus.UNPROCESSABLE_ENTITY, "Wrong HTTP status code")
+        self.assertIn(norm("Error at vld[id='{}']:ip-profile-ref"
+                           " You cannot set an ip-profile when mgmt-network is True"
+                           .format(vld["id"])),
+                      norm(str(e.exception)), "Wrong exception text")
+
+    def test_validate_vld_connection_point_refs_on_valid_descriptor(self):
+        indata = deepcopy(db_nsd_content)
+        vld = indata['vld'][0]
+        self.topic.validate_vld_connection_point_refs(vld, indata)
+
+    def test_validate_vld_connection_point_refs_when_missing_constituent_vnfd(self):
+        indata = deepcopy(db_nsd_content)
+        vld = indata['vld'][0]
+        vnfd_cp = vld['vnfd-connection-point-ref'][0]
+        indata['constituent-vnfd'] = []
+        with self.assertRaises(EngineException) as e:
+            self.topic.validate_vld_connection_point_refs(vld, indata)
+        self.assertEqual(e.exception.http_code, HTTPStatus.UNPROCESSABLE_ENTITY, "Wrong HTTP status code")
+        self.assertIn(norm("Error at vld[id='{}']:vnfd-connection-point-ref[member-vnf-index-ref='{}'] "
+                           "does not match any constituent-vnfd:member-vnf-index"
+                           .format(vld["id"], vnfd_cp["member-vnf-index-ref"])),
+                      norm(str(e.exception)), "Wrong exception text")
+
+    def test_validate_vld_connection_point_refs_on_unmatched_constituent_vnfd(self):
+        indata = deepcopy(db_nsd_content)
+        vld = indata['vld'][0]
+        vnfd_cp = vld['vnfd-connection-point-ref'][0]
+        constituent_vnfd = indata['constituent-vnfd'][0]
+        constituent_vnfd['vnfd-id-ref'] = 'unmatched-vnfd-id-ref'
+        with self.assertRaises(EngineException) as e:
+            self.topic.validate_vld_connection_point_refs(vld, indata)
+        self.assertEqual(e.exception.http_code, HTTPStatus.UNPROCESSABLE_ENTITY, "Wrong HTTP status code")
+        self.assertIn(norm("Error at vld[id='{}']:vnfd-connection-point-ref[vnfd-id-ref='{}'] "
+                           "does not match constituent-vnfd[member-vnf-index='{}']:vnfd-id-ref"
+                           " '{}'".format(vld["id"], vnfd_cp["vnfd-id-ref"],
+                                          constituent_vnfd["member-vnf-index"],
+                                          constituent_vnfd["vnfd-id-ref"])),
+                      norm(str(e.exception)), "Wrong exception text")
+
+    def test_validate_vld_connection_point_refs_vnfd_connection_points_on_valid_descriptor(self):
+        nsd_descriptor = deepcopy(db_nsd_content)
+        vnfd_1_descriptor = deepcopy(db_vnfd_content)
+        vnfd_2_descriptor = deepcopy(db_vnfd_content)
+        vld = nsd_descriptor['vld'][0]
+        member_vnfd_index = {'1': vnfd_1_descriptor, '2': vnfd_2_descriptor}
+        self.topic.validate_vld_connection_point_refs_vnfd_connection_points(vld, member_vnfd_index)
+
+    def test_validate_vld_connection_point_refs_vnfd_connection_points_when_missing_connection_point(self):
+        nsd_descriptor = deepcopy(db_nsd_content)
+        vnfd_1_descriptor = deepcopy(db_vnfd_content)
+        vnfd_2_descriptor = deepcopy(db_vnfd_content)
+        vld = nsd_descriptor['vld'][0]
+        referenced_vnfd_cp = vld['vnfd-connection-point-ref'][0]
+        member_vnfd_index = {'1': vnfd_1_descriptor, '2': vnfd_2_descriptor}
+        vnfd_1_descriptor['connection-point'] = []
+        with self.assertRaises(EngineException) as e:
+            self.topic.validate_vld_connection_point_refs_vnfd_connection_points(vld, member_vnfd_index)
+        self.assertEqual(e.exception.http_code, HTTPStatus.UNPROCESSABLE_ENTITY, "Wrong HTTP status code")
+        self.assertIn(norm("Error at vld[id='{}']:vnfd-connection-point-ref[member-vnf-index-ref='{}']:vnfd-"
+                           "connection-point-ref='{}' references a non existing conection-point:name inside vnfd '{}'"
+                           .format(vld["id"], referenced_vnfd_cp["member-vnf-index-ref"],
+                                   referenced_vnfd_cp["vnfd-connection-point-ref"], vnfd_1_descriptor["id"])),
+                      norm(str(e.exception)), "Wrong exception text")
+
+    def test_check_conflict_on_edit_when_missing_vnfd_index(self):
+        nsd_descriptor = deepcopy(db_nsd_content)
+        invalid_vnfd_id_ref = 'invalid-vnfd-id-ref'
+        nsd_descriptor['id'] = 'invalid-vnfd-id-ns'
+        nsd_descriptor['constituent-vnfd'][0]['vnfd-id-ref'] = invalid_vnfd_id_ref
+        nsd_descriptor['vld'][0]['vnfd-connection-point-ref'][0]['vnfd-id-ref'] = invalid_vnfd_id_ref
+        nsd_descriptor['vld'][1]['vnfd-connection-point-ref'][0]['vnfd-id-ref'] = invalid_vnfd_id_ref
+        with self.assertRaises(EngineException) as e:
+            self.db.get_list.return_value = []
+            self.topic.check_conflict_on_edit(fake_session, nsd_descriptor, [], 'id')
+        self.assertEqual(e.exception.http_code, HTTPStatus.CONFLICT, "Wrong HTTP status code")
+        self.assertIn(norm("Descriptor error at 'constituent-vnfd':'vnfd-id-ref'='{}' references a non "
+                           "existing vnfd".format(invalid_vnfd_id_ref)),
+                      norm(str(e.exception)), "Wrong exception text")
+
 
 if __name__ == '__main__':
     unittest.main()