fixed issue where kafka message is sent before database update
[osm/LCM.git] / osm_lcm / lcm.py
index 6b98137..b9417f2 100644 (file)
@@ -3,19 +3,17 @@
 
 import asyncio
 import yaml
-import ROclient
 import logging
 import logging.handlers
 import getopt
 import functools
 import sys
 import traceback
-from osm_common import dbmemory
-from osm_common import dbmongo
-from osm_common import fslocal
-from osm_common import msglocal
-from osm_common import msgkafka
-from osm_common.dbbase import DbException
+import ROclient
+# from osm_lcm import version as lcm_version, version_date as lcm_version_date, ROclient
+from osm_common import dbmemory, dbmongo, fslocal, msglocal, msgkafka
+from osm_common import version as common_version
+from osm_common.dbbase import DbException, deep_update
 from osm_common.fsbase import FsException
 from osm_common.msgbase import MsgException
 from os import environ, path
@@ -30,8 +28,21 @@ from time import time
 
 __author__ = "Alfonso Tierno"
 min_RO_version = [0, 5, 72]
+min_n2vc_version = "0.0.2"
+min_common_version = "0.1.7"
+# uncomment if LCM is installed as library and installed, and get them from __init__.py
+lcm_version = '0.1.15'
+lcm_version_date = '2018-09-13'
 
 
+def versiontuple(v):
+    """utility for compare dot separate versions. Fills with zeros to proper number comparison"""
+    filled = []
+    for point in v.split("."):
+        filled.append(point.zfill(8))
+    return tuple(filled)
+
 class LcmException(Exception):
     pass
 
@@ -123,9 +134,10 @@ class TaskRegistry:
             for task_name, task in self.task_registry[topic][_id][op_id].items():
                 if target_task_name and target_task_name != task_name:
                     continue
-                result = task.cancel()
-                if result:
-                    self.logger.debug("{} _id={} order_id={} task={} cancelled".format(topic, _id, op_id, task_name))
+                # result =
+                task.cancel()
+                # if result:
+                #     self.logger.debug("{} _id={} order_id={} task={} cancelled".format(topic, _id, op_id, task_name))
 
 
 class Lcm:
@@ -165,12 +177,12 @@ class Lcm:
         config["database"]["logger_name"] = "lcm.db"
         config["storage"]["logger_name"] = "lcm.fs"
         config["message"]["logger_name"] = "lcm.msg"
-        if "logfile" in config["global"]:
+        if config["global"].get("logfile"):
             file_handler = logging.handlers.RotatingFileHandler(config["global"]["logfile"],
                                                                 maxBytes=100e6, backupCount=9, delay=0)
             file_handler.setFormatter(log_formatter_simple)
             self.logger.addHandler(file_handler)
-        else:
+        if not config["global"].get("nologging"):
             str_handler = logging.StreamHandler()
             str_handler.setFormatter(log_formatter_simple)
             self.logger.addHandler(str_handler)
@@ -182,14 +194,14 @@ class Lcm:
         for k1, logname in {"message": "lcm.msg", "database": "lcm.db", "storage": "lcm.fs"}.items():
             config[k1]["logger_name"] = logname
             logger_module = logging.getLogger(logname)
-            if "logfile" in config[k1]:
+            if config[k1].get("logfile"):
                 file_handler = logging.handlers.RotatingFileHandler(config[k1]["logfile"],
                                                                     maxBytes=100e6, backupCount=9, delay=0)
                 file_handler.setFormatter(log_formatter_simple)
                 logger_module.addHandler(file_handler)
-            if "loglevel" in config[k1]:
+            if config[k1].get("loglevel"):
                 logger_module.setLevel(config[k1]["loglevel"])
-
+        self.logger.critical("starting osm/lcm version {} {}".format(lcm_version, lcm_version_date))
         self.n2vc = N2VC(
             log=self.logger,
             server=config['VCA']['host'],
@@ -205,8 +217,12 @@ class Lcm:
         # check version of N2VC
         # TODO enhance with int conversion or from distutils.version import LooseVersion
         # or with list(map(int, version.split(".")))
-        if N2VC_version < "0.0.2":
-            raise LcmException("Not compatible osm/N2VC version '{}'. Needed '0.0.2' or higher".format(N2VC_version))
+        if versiontuple(N2VC_version) < versiontuple(min_n2vc_version):
+            raise LcmException("Not compatible osm/N2VC version '{}'. Needed '{}' or higher".format(
+                N2VC_version, min_n2vc_version))
+        if versiontuple(common_version) < versiontuple("0.1.7"):
+            raise LcmException("Not compatible osm/common version '{}'. Needed '{}' or higher".format(
+                common_version, min_common_version))
 
         try:
             # TODO check database version
@@ -657,8 +673,7 @@ class Lcm:
             if ci_file:
                 ci_file.close()
 
-    def n2vc_callback(self, model_name, application_name, status, message, db_nsr, db_nslcmop, member_vnf_index,
-                      task=None):
+    def n2vc_callback(self, model_name, application_name, status, message, n2vc_info, task=None):
         """
         Callback both for charm status change and task completion
         :param model_name: Charm model name
@@ -673,120 +688,65 @@ class Lcm:
             - removing,
             - removed
         :param message: detailed message error
-        :param db_nsr: nsr database content
-        :param db_nslcmop: nslcmop database content
-        :param member_vnf_index: NSD member-vnf-index
+        :param n2vc_info dictionary with information shared with instantiate task. Contains:
+            nsr_id:
+            nslcmop_id:
+            lcmOperationType: currently "instantiate"
+            deployed: dictionary with {<application>: {operational-status: <status>, detailed-status: <text>}}
+            db_update: dictionary to be filled with the changes to be wrote to database with format key.key.key: value
+            n2vc_event: event used to notify instantiation task that some change has been produced
         :param task: None for charm status change, or task for completion task callback
         :return:
         """
-        nsr_id = None
-        nslcmop_id = None
-        db_nsr_update = {}
-        db_nslcmop_update = {}
         try:
-            nsr_id = db_nsr["_id"]
-            nslcmop_id = db_nslcmop["_id"]
-            nsr_lcm = db_nsr["_admin"]["deployed"]
-            ns_operation = db_nslcmop["lcmOperationType"]
-            logging_text = "Task ns={} {}={} [n2vc_callback] vnf_index={}".format(nsr_id, ns_operation, nslcmop_id,
-                                                                                  member_vnf_index)
+            nsr_id = n2vc_info["nsr_id"]
+            deployed = n2vc_info["deployed"]
+            db_nsr_update = n2vc_info["db_update"]
+            nslcmop_id = n2vc_info["nslcmop_id"]
+            ns_operation = n2vc_info["lcmOperationType"]
+            n2vc_event = n2vc_info["n2vc_event"]
+            logging_text = "Task ns={} {}={} [n2vc_callback] application={}".format(nsr_id, ns_operation, nslcmop_id,
+                                                                                    application_name)
+            vca_deployed = deployed.get(application_name)
+            if not vca_deployed:
+                self.logger.error(logging_text + " Not present at nsr._admin.deployed.VCA")
+                return
 
             if task:
                 if task.cancelled():
                     self.logger.debug(logging_text + " task Cancelled")
-                    # TODO update db_nslcmop
-                    return
+                    vca_deployed['operational-status'] = "error"
+                    db_nsr_update["_admin.deployed.VCA.{}.operational-status".format(application_name)] = "error"
+                    vca_deployed['detailed-status'] = "Task Cancelled"
+                    db_nsr_update["_admin.deployed.VCA.{}.detailed-status".format(application_name)] = "Task Cancelled"
 
-                if task.done():
+                elif task.done():
                     exc = task.exception()
                     if exc:
                         self.logger.error(logging_text + " task Exception={}".format(exc))
-                        if ns_operation in ("instantiate", "terminate"):
-                            nsr_lcm["VCA"][member_vnf_index]['operational-status'] = "error"
-                            db_nsr_update["_admin.deployed.VCA.{}.operational-status".format(member_vnf_index)] = \
-                                "error"
-                            nsr_lcm["VCA"][member_vnf_index]['detailed-status'] = str(exc)
-                            db_nsr_update[
-                                "_admin.deployed.VCA.{}.detailed-status".format(member_vnf_index)] = str(exc)
-                        elif ns_operation == "action":
-                            db_nslcmop_update["operationState"] = "FAILED"
-                            db_nslcmop_update["detailed-status"] = str(exc)
-                            db_nslcmop_update["statusEnteredTime"] = time()
-                            return
-
+                        vca_deployed['operational-status'] = "error"
+                        db_nsr_update["_admin.deployed.VCA.{}.operational-status".format(application_name)] = "error"
+                        vca_deployed['detailed-status'] = str(exc)
+                        db_nsr_update["_admin.deployed.VCA.{}.detailed-status".format(application_name)] = str(exc)
                     else:
                         self.logger.debug(logging_text + " task Done")
-                        # TODO revise with Adam if action is finished and ok when task is done
-                        if ns_operation == "action":
-                            db_nslcmop_update["operationState"] = "COMPLETED"
-                            db_nslcmop_update["detailed-status"] = "Done"
-                            db_nslcmop_update["statusEnteredTime"] = time()
                         # task is Done, but callback is still ongoing. So ignore
                         return
             elif status:
                 self.logger.debug(logging_text + " Enter status={}".format(status))
-                if nsr_lcm["VCA"][member_vnf_index]['operational-status'] == status:
+                if vca_deployed['operational-status'] == status:
                     return  # same status, ignore
-                nsr_lcm["VCA"][member_vnf_index]['operational-status'] = status
-                db_nsr_update["_admin.deployed.VCA.{}.operational-status".format(member_vnf_index)] = status
-                nsr_lcm["VCA"][member_vnf_index]['detailed-status'] = str(message)
-                db_nsr_update["_admin.deployed.VCA.{}.detailed-status".format(member_vnf_index)] = str(message)
+                vca_deployed['operational-status'] = status
+                db_nsr_update["_admin.deployed.VCA.{}.operational-status".format(application_name)] = status
+                vca_deployed['detailed-status'] = str(message)
+                db_nsr_update["_admin.deployed.VCA.{}.detailed-status".format(application_name)] = str(message)
             else:
                 self.logger.critical(logging_text + " Enter with bad parameters", exc_info=True)
                 return
-
-            all_active = True
-            status_map = {}
-            n2vc_error_text = []   # contain text error list. If empty no one is in error status
-            for vnf_index, vca_info in nsr_lcm["VCA"].items():
-                vca_status = vca_info["operational-status"]
-                if vca_status not in status_map:
-                    # Initialize it
-                    status_map[vca_status] = 0
-                status_map[vca_status] += 1
-
-                if vca_status != "active":
-                    all_active = False
-                if vca_status in ("error", "blocked"):
-                    n2vc_error_text.append("member_vnf_index={} {}: {}".format(member_vnf_index, vca_status,
-                                                                               vca_info["detailed-status"]))
-
-            if all_active:
-                self.logger.debug("[n2vc_callback] ns_instantiate={} vnf_index={} All active".format(nsr_id,
-                                                                                                     member_vnf_index))
-                db_nsr_update["config-status"] = "configured"
-                db_nsr_update["detailed-status"] = "done"
-                db_nslcmop_update["operationState"] = "COMPLETED"
-                db_nslcmop_update["detailed-status"] = "Done"
-                db_nslcmop_update["statusEnteredTime"] = time()
-            elif n2vc_error_text:
-                db_nsr_update["config-status"] = "failed"
-                error_text = "fail configuring " + ";".join(n2vc_error_text)
-                db_nsr_update["detailed-status"] = error_text
-                db_nslcmop_update["operationState"] = "FAILED_TEMP"
-                db_nslcmop_update["detailed-status"] = error_text
-                db_nslcmop_update["statusEnteredTime"] = time()
-            else:
-                cs = "configuring: "
-                separator = ""
-                for status, num in status_map.items():
-                    cs += separator + "{}: {}".format(status, num)
-                    separator = ", "
-                db_nsr_update["config-status"] = cs
-                db_nsr_update["detailed-status"] = cs
-                db_nslcmop_update["detailed-status"] = cs
-
+            # wake up instantiate task
+            n2vc_event.set()
         except Exception as e:
-            self.logger.critical("[n2vc_callback] vnf_index={} Exception {}".format(member_vnf_index, e), exc_info=True)
-        finally:
-            try:
-                if db_nslcmop_update:
-                    self.update_db_2("nslcmops", nslcmop_id, db_nslcmop_update)
-                if db_nsr_update:
-                    self.update_db_2("nsrs", nsr_id, db_nsr_update)
-            except Exception as e:
-                self.logger.critical("[n2vc_callback] vnf_index={} Update database Exception {}".format(
-                    member_vnf_index, e), exc_info=True)
+            self.logger.critical(logging_text + " Exception {}".format(e), exc_info=True)
 
     def ns_params_2_RO(self, ns_params, nsd, vnfd_dict):
         """
@@ -811,7 +771,12 @@ class Lcm:
         def ip_profile_2_RO(ip_profile):
             RO_ip_profile = deepcopy((ip_profile))
             if "dns-server" in RO_ip_profile:
-                RO_ip_profile["dns-address"] = RO_ip_profile.pop("dns-server")
+                if isinstance(RO_ip_profile["dns-server"], list):
+                    RO_ip_profile["dns-address"] = []
+                    for ds in RO_ip_profile.pop("dns-server"):
+                        RO_ip_profile["dns-address"].append(ds['address'])
+                else:
+                    RO_ip_profile["dns-address"] = RO_ip_profile.pop("dns-server")
             if RO_ip_profile.get("ip-version") == "ipv4":
                 RO_ip_profile["ip-version"] = "IPv4"
             if RO_ip_profile.get("ip-version") == "ipv6":
@@ -881,15 +846,15 @@ class Lcm:
                                 for vdu_descriptor in vnf_descriptor["vdu"]:
                                     for vdu_interface in vdu_descriptor["interface"]:
                                         if vdu_interface.get("internal-connection-point-ref") == icp_params["id-ref"]:
-                                            if vdu_descriptor["id"] not in RO_vnf["vdus"]:
-                                                RO_vnf["vdus"][vdu_descriptor["id"]] = {}
-                                            if "interfaces" not in RO_vnf["vdus"][vdu_descriptor["id"]]:
-                                                RO_vnf["vdus"][vdu_descriptor["id"]]["interfaces"] = {}
-                                            RO_ifaces = RO_vnf["vdus"][vdu_descriptor["id"]]["interfaces"]
-                                            if vdu_interface["name"] not in RO_ifaces:
-                                                RO_ifaces[vdu_interface["name"]] = {}
-
-                                            RO_ifaces[vdu_interface["name"]]["ip_address"] = icp_params["ip-address"]
+                                            RO_interface_update = {}
+                                            if icp_params.get("ip-address"):
+                                                RO_interface_update["ip_address"] = icp_params["ip-address"]
+                                            if icp_params.get("mac-address"):
+                                                RO_interface_update["mac_address"] = icp_params["mac-address"]
+                                            if RO_interface_update:
+                                                RO_vnf_update = {"vdus": {vdu_descriptor["id"]: {
+                                                    "interfaces": {vdu_interface["name"]: RO_interface_update}}}}
+                                                deep_update(RO_vnf, RO_vnf_update)
                                             iface_found = True
                                             break
                                     if iface_found:
@@ -921,46 +886,56 @@ class Lcm:
                             })
                     else:  # isinstance str
                         RO_vld["sites"].append({"netmap-use": vld_params["vim-network-name"]})
+                if "vnfd-connection-point-ref" in vld_params:
+                    for cp_params in vld_params["vnfd-connection-point-ref"]:
+                        # look for interface
+                        for constituent_vnfd in nsd["constituent-vnfd"]:
+                            if constituent_vnfd["member-vnf-index"] == cp_params["member-vnf-index-ref"]:
+                                vnf_descriptor = vnfd_dict[constituent_vnfd["vnfd-id-ref"]]
+                                break
+                        else:
+                            raise LcmException(
+                                "Invalid instantiate parameter vld:vnfd-connection-point-ref:member-vnf-index-ref={} "
+                                "is not present at nsd:constituent-vnfd".format(cp_params["member-vnf-index-ref"]))
+                        match_cp = False
+                        for vdu_descriptor in vnf_descriptor["vdu"]:
+                            for interface_descriptor in vdu_descriptor["interface"]:
+                                if interface_descriptor.get("external-connection-point-ref") == \
+                                        cp_params["vnfd-connection-point-ref"]:
+                                    match_cp = True
+                                    break
+                            if match_cp:
+                                break
+                        else:
+                            raise LcmException(
+                                "Invalid instantiate parameter vld:vnfd-connection-point-ref:member-vnf-index-ref={}:"
+                                "vnfd-connection-point-ref={} is not present at vnfd={}".format(
+                                    cp_params["member-vnf-index-ref"],
+                                    cp_params["vnfd-connection-point-ref"],
+                                    vnf_descriptor["id"]))
+                        RO_cp_params = {}
+                        if cp_params.get("ip-address"):
+                            RO_cp_params["ip_address"] = cp_params["ip-address"]
+                        if cp_params.get("mac-address"):
+                            RO_cp_params["mac_address"] = cp_params["mac-address"]
+                        if RO_cp_params:
+                            RO_vnf_params = {
+                                cp_params["member-vnf-index-ref"]: {
+                                    "vdus": {
+                                        vdu_descriptor["id"]: {
+                                            "interfaces": {
+                                                interface_descriptor["name"]: RO_cp_params
+                                            }
+                                        }
+                                    }
+                                }
+                            }
+                            deep_update(RO_ns_params["vnfs"], RO_vnf_params)
                 if RO_vld:
                     RO_ns_params["networks"][vld_params["name"]] = RO_vld
         return RO_ns_params
 
-    def ns_update_vnfr(self, db_vnfrs, ns_RO_info):
-        """
-        Updates database vnfr with the RO info, e.g. ip_address, vim_id... Descriptor db_vnfrs is also updated
-        :param db_vnfrs:
-        :param ns_RO_info:
-        :return:
-        """
-        for vnf_index, db_vnfr in db_vnfrs.items():
-            vnfr_deployed = ns_RO_info.get(vnf_index)
-            if not vnfr_deployed:
-                continue
-            vnfr_update = {}
-            db_vnfr["ip-address"] = vnfr_update["ip-address"] = vnfr_deployed.get("ip_address")
-            for index, vdur in enumerate(db_vnfr["vdur"]):
-                vdu_deployed = vnfr_deployed["vdur"].get(vdur["vdu-id-ref"])
-                if not vdu_deployed:
-                    continue
-                vnfr_update["vdur.{}.vim-id".format(index)] = vdu_deployed.get("vim_id")
-                db_vnfr["vdur"][index]["vim-id"] = vnfr_update["vdur.{}.vim-id".format(index)]
-                vnfr_update["vdur.{}.ip-address".format(index)] = vdu_deployed.get("ip_address")
-                db_vnfr["vdur"][index]["ip-address"] = vnfr_update["vdur.{}.ip-address".format(index)]
-                for index2, interface in enumerate(vdur["interfaces"]):
-                    iface_deployed = vdu_deployed["interfaces"].get(interface["name"])
-                    if not iface_deployed:
-                        continue
-                    db_vnfr["vdur"][index]["interfaces"][index2]["vim-id"] =\
-                        vnfr_update["vdur.{}.interfaces.{}.vim-id".format(index, index2)] = iface_deployed.get("vim_id")
-                    db_vnfr["vdur"][index]["interfaces"][index2]["ip-address"] =\
-                        vnfr_update["vdur.{}.interfaces.{}.ip-address".format(index, index2)] = iface_deployed.get(
-                        "ip_address")
-                    db_vnfr["vdur"][index]["interfaces"][index2]["mac-address"] =\
-                        vnfr_update["vdur.{}.interfaces.{}.mac-address".format(index, index2)] = iface_deployed.get(
-                        "mac_address")
-            self.update_db_2("vnfrs", db_vnfr["_id"], vnfr_update)
-
-    def ns_update_vnfr_2(self, db_vnfrs, nsr_desc_RO):
+    def ns_update_vnfr(self, db_vnfrs, nsr_desc_RO):
         """
         Updates database vnfr with the RO info, e.g. ip_address, vim_id... Descriptor db_vnfrs is also updated
         :param db_vnfrs:
@@ -996,7 +971,7 @@ class Lcm:
                     break
 
             else:
-                raise LcmException("ns_update_vnfr_2: Not found member_vnf_index={} at RO info".format(vnf_index))
+                raise LcmException("ns_update_vnfr: Not found member_vnf_index={} at RO info".format(vnf_index))
 
     async def create_monitoring(self, nsr_id, vnf_member_index, vnfd_desc):
         if not vnfd_desc.get("scaling-group-descriptor"):
@@ -1050,9 +1025,11 @@ class Lcm:
         db_nslcmop = None
         db_nsr_update = {}
         db_nslcmop_update = {}
+        nslcmop_operation_state = None
         db_vnfrs = {}
         RO_descriptor_number = 0   # number of descriptors created at RO
         descriptor_id_2_RO = {}    # map between vnfd/nsd id to the id used at RO
+        n2vc_info = {}
         exc = None
         try:
             step = "Getting nslcmop={} from db".format(nslcmop_id)
@@ -1233,8 +1210,7 @@ class Lcm:
                 raise ROclient.ROClientException("Timeout waiting ns to be ready")
 
             step = "Updating VNFRs"
-            # self.ns_update_vnfr(db_vnfrs, ns_RO_info)
-            self.ns_update_vnfr_2(db_vnfrs, desc)
+            self.ns_update_vnfr(db_vnfrs, desc)
 
             db_nsr["detailed-status"] = "Configuring vnfr"
             self.update_db_2("nsrs", nsr_id, db_nsr_update)
@@ -1242,10 +1218,12 @@ class Lcm:
             # The parameters we'll need to deploy a charm
             number_to_configure = 0
 
-            def deploy():
+            def deploy(vnf_index, vdu_id, mgmt_ip_address, n2vc_info, config_primitive=None):
                 """An inner function to deploy the charm from either vnf or vdu
+                vnf_index is mandatory. vdu_id can be None for a vnf configuration or the id for vdu configuration
                 """
-
+                if not mgmt_ip_address:
+                    raise LcmException("vnfd/vdu has not management ip address to configure it")
                 # Login to the VCA.
                 # if number_to_configure == 0:
                 #     self.logger.debug("Logging into N2VC...")
@@ -1267,19 +1245,26 @@ class Lcm:
                 )
 
                 # Setup the runtime parameters for this VNF
-                params['rw_mgmt_ip'] = db_vnfrs[vnf_index]["ip-address"]
+                params = {'rw_mgmt_ip': mgmt_ip_address}
+                if config_primitive:
+                    params["initial-config-primitive"] = config_primitive
 
                 # ns_name will be ignored in the current version of N2VC
                 # but will be implemented for the next point release.
                 model_name = 'default'
+                vdu_id_text = "vnfd"
+                if vdu_id:
+                    vdu_id_text = vdu_id
                 application_name = self.n2vc.FormatApplicationName(
                     nsr_name,
                     vnf_index,
-                    vnfd['name'],
+                    vdu_id_text
                 )
                 if not nsr_lcm.get("VCA"):
                     nsr_lcm["VCA"] = {}
-                nsr_lcm["VCA"][vnf_index] = db_nsr_update["_admin.deployed.VCA.{}".format(vnf_index)] = {
+                nsr_lcm["VCA"][application_name] = db_nsr_update["_admin.deployed.VCA.{}".format(application_name)] = {
+                    "member-vnf-index": vnf_index,
+                    "vdu_id": vdu_id,
                     "model": model_name,
                     "application": application_name,
                     "operational-status": "init",
@@ -1290,6 +1275,13 @@ class Lcm:
 
                 self.logger.debug("Task create_ns={} Passing artifacts path '{}' for {}".format(nsr_id, charm_path,
                                                                                                 proxy_charm))
+                if not n2vc_info:
+                    n2vc_info["nsr_id"] = nsr_id
+                    n2vc_info["nslcmop_id"] = nslcmop_id
+                    n2vc_info["n2vc_event"] = asyncio.Event(loop=self.loop)
+                    n2vc_info["lcmOperationType"] = "instantiate"
+                    n2vc_info["deployed"] = nsr_lcm["VCA"]
+                    n2vc_info["db_update"] = db_nsr_update
                 task = asyncio.ensure_future(
                     self.n2vc.DeployCharms(
                         model_name,          # The network service name
@@ -1299,15 +1291,13 @@ class Lcm:
                         params,              # Runtime params, like mgmt ip
                         {},                  # for native charms only
                         self.n2vc_callback,  # Callback for status changes
-                        db_nsr,              # Callback parameter
-                        db_nslcmop,
-                        vnf_index,           # Callback parameter
+                        n2vc_info,              # Callback parameter
                         None,                # Callback parameter (task)
                     )
                 )
                 task.add_done_callback(functools.partial(self.n2vc_callback, model_name, application_name, None, None,
-                                                         db_nsr, db_nslcmop, vnf_index))
-                self.lcm_tasks.register("ns", nsr_id, nslcmop_id, "create_charm:" + vnf_index, task)
+                                                         n2vc_info))
+                self.lcm_tasks.register("ns", nsr_id, nslcmop_id, "create_charm:" + application_name, task)
 
             step = "Looking for needed vnfd to configure"
             self.logger.debug(logging_text + step)
@@ -1322,58 +1312,108 @@ class Lcm:
 
                 if vnf_config and vnf_config.get("juju"):
                     proxy_charm = vnf_config["juju"]["charm"]
-                    params = {}
+                    config_primitive = None
 
                     if proxy_charm:
                         if 'initial-config-primitive' in vnf_config:
-                            params['initial-config-primitive'] = vnf_config['initial-config-primitive']
+                            config_primitive = vnf_config['initial-config-primitive']
 
                         # Login to the VCA. If there are multiple calls to login(),
                         # subsequent calls will be a nop and return immediately.
                         step = "connecting to N2VC to configure vnf {}".format(vnf_index)
                         await self.n2vc.login()
-                        deploy()
+                        deploy(vnf_index, None, db_vnfrs[vnf_index]["ip-address"], n2vc_info, config_primitive)
                         number_to_configure += 1
 
                 # Deploy charms for each VDU that supports one.
+                vdu_index = 0
                 for vdu in vnfd['vdu']:
                     vdu_config = vdu.get('vdu-configuration')
                     proxy_charm = None
-                    params = {}
+                    config_primitive = None
 
                     if vdu_config and vdu_config.get("juju"):
                         proxy_charm = vdu_config["juju"]["charm"]
 
                         if 'initial-config-primitive' in vdu_config:
-                            params['initial-config-primitive'] = vdu_config['initial-config-primitive']
+                            config_primitive = vdu_config['initial-config-primitive']
 
                         if proxy_charm:
                             step = "connecting to N2VC to configure vdu {} from vnf {}".format(vdu["id"], vnf_index)
                             await self.n2vc.login()
-                            deploy()
+                            deploy(vnf_index, vdu["id"], db_vnfrs[vnf_index]["vdur"][vdu_index]["ip-address"],
+                                   n2vc_info, config_primitive)
                             number_to_configure += 1
+                    vdu_index += 1
 
+            db_nsr_update["operational-status"] = "running"
+            configuration_failed = False
             if number_to_configure:
-                db_nsr_update["config-status"] = "configuring"
-                db_nsr_update["operational-status"] = "running"
-                db_nsr_update["detailed-status"] = "configuring: init: {}".format(number_to_configure)
-                db_nslcmop_update["detailed-status"] = "configuring: init: {}".format(number_to_configure)
-            else:
-                db_nslcmop_update["operationState"] = "COMPLETED"
+                old_status = "configuring: init: {}".format(number_to_configure)
+                db_nsr_update["config-status"] = old_status
+                db_nsr_update["detailed-status"] = old_status
+                db_nslcmop_update["detailed-status"] = old_status
+
+                # wait until all are configured.
+                while True:
+                    if db_nsr_update:
+                        self.update_db_2("nsrs", nsr_id, db_nsr_update)
+                    if db_nslcmop_update:
+                        self.update_db_2("nslcmops", nslcmop_id, db_nslcmop_update)
+                    await n2vc_info["n2vc_event"].wait()
+                    n2vc_info["n2vc_event"].clear()
+                    all_active = True
+                    status_map = {}
+                    n2vc_error_text = []  # contain text error list. If empty no one is in error status
+                    for _, vca_info in nsr_lcm["VCA"].items():
+                        vca_status = vca_info["operational-status"]
+                        if vca_status not in status_map:
+                            # Initialize it
+                            status_map[vca_status] = 0
+                        status_map[vca_status] += 1
+
+                        if vca_status != "active":
+                            all_active = False
+                        if vca_status in ("error", "blocked"):
+                            n2vc_error_text.append(
+                                "member_vnf_index={} vdu_id={} {}: {}".format(vca_info["member-vnf-index"],
+                                                                              vca_info["vdu_id"], vca_status,
+                                                                              vca_info["detailed-status"]))
+
+                    if all_active:
+                        break
+                    elif n2vc_error_text:
+                        db_nsr_update["config-status"] = "failed"
+                        error_text = "fail configuring " + ";".join(n2vc_error_text)
+                        db_nsr_update["detailed-status"] = error_text
+                        db_nslcmop_update["operationState"] = nslcmop_operation_state = "FAILED_TEMP"
+                        db_nslcmop_update["detailed-status"] = error_text
+                        db_nslcmop_update["statusEnteredTime"] = time()
+                        configuration_failed = True
+                        break
+                    else:
+                        cs = "configuring: "
+                        separator = ""
+                        for status, num in status_map.items():
+                            cs += separator + "{}: {}".format(status, num)
+                            separator = ", "
+                        if old_status != cs:
+                            db_nsr_update["config-status"] = cs
+                            db_nsr_update["detailed-status"] = cs
+                            db_nslcmop_update["detailed-status"] = cs
+                            old_status = cs
+
+            if not configuration_failed:
+                # all is done
+                db_nslcmop_update["operationState"] = nslcmop_operation_state = "COMPLETED"
                 db_nslcmop_update["statusEnteredTime"] = time()
                 db_nslcmop_update["detailed-status"] = "done"
                 db_nsr_update["config-status"] = "configured"
                 db_nsr_update["detailed-status"] = "done"
-                db_nsr_update["operational-status"] = "running"
-            step = "Sending monitoring parameters to PM"
+
+            step = "Sending monitoring parameters to PM"
             # for c_vnf in nsd["constituent-vnfd"]:
             #     await self.create_monitoring(nsr_id, c_vnf["member-vnf-index"], needed_vnfd[c_vnf["vnfd-id-ref"]])
-            try:
-                await self.msg.aiowrite("ns", "instantiated", {"nsr_id": nsr_id, "nslcmop_id": nslcmop_id})
-            except Exception as e:
-                self.logger.error(logging_text + "kafka_write notification Exception {}".format(e))
-
-            self.logger.debug(logging_text + "Exit")
             return
 
         except (ROclient.ROClientException, DbException, LcmException) as e:
@@ -1393,12 +1433,20 @@ class Lcm:
                     db_nsr_update["operational-status"] = "failed"
                 if db_nslcmop:
                     db_nslcmop_update["detailed-status"] = "FAILED {}: {}".format(step, exc)
-                    db_nslcmop_update["operationState"] = "FAILED"
+                    db_nslcmop_update["operationState"] = nslcmop_operation_state = "FAILED"
                     db_nslcmop_update["statusEnteredTime"] = time()
             if db_nsr_update:
                 self.update_db_2("nsrs", nsr_id, db_nsr_update)
             if db_nslcmop_update:
                 self.update_db_2("nslcmops", nslcmop_id, db_nslcmop_update)
+            if nslcmop_operation_state:
+                try:
+                    await self.msg.aiowrite("ns", "instantiated", {"nsr_id": nsr_id, "nslcmop_id": nslcmop_id,
+                                                                   "operationState": nslcmop_operation_state})
+                except Exception as e:
+                    self.logger.error(logging_text + "kafka_write notification Exception {}".format(e))
+
+            self.logger.debug(logging_text + "Exit")
             self.lcm_tasks.remove("ns", nsr_id, nslcmop_id, "ns_instantiate")
 
     async def ns_terminate(self, nsr_id, nslcmop_id):
@@ -1412,6 +1460,7 @@ class Lcm:
         vca_task_dict = {}
         db_nsr_update = {}
         db_nslcmop_update = {}
+        nslcmop_operation_state = None
         try:
             step = "Getting nslcmop={} from db".format(nslcmop_id)
             db_nslcmop = self.db.get_one("nslcmops", {"_id": nslcmop_id})
@@ -1435,52 +1484,84 @@ class Lcm:
                     db_nsr_update["detailed-status"] = "Deleting charms"
                     self.logger.debug(logging_text + step)
                     self.update_db_2("nsrs", nsr_id, db_nsr_update)
-                    for vnf_index, deploy_info in nsr_lcm["VCA"].items():
-                        if deploy_info and deploy_info.get("application"):
+                    for application_name, deploy_info in nsr_lcm["VCA"].items():
+                        if deploy_info:  # TODO it would be desirable having a and deploy_info.get("deployed"):
                             task = asyncio.ensure_future(
                                 self.n2vc.RemoveCharms(
                                     deploy_info['model'],
-                                    deploy_info['application'],
+                                    application_name,
                                     # self.n2vc_callback,
                                     # db_nsr,
                                     # db_nslcmop,
-                                    # vnf_index,
                                 )
                             )
                             vca_task_list.append(task)
-                            vca_task_dict[vnf_index] = task
+                            vca_task_dict[application_name] = task
                             # task.add_done_callback(functools.partial(self.n2vc_callback, deploy_info['model'],
                             #                                          deploy_info['application'], None, db_nsr,
                             #                                          db_nslcmop, vnf_index))
-                            self.lcm_ns_tasks[nsr_id][nslcmop_id]["delete_charm:" + vnf_index] = task
+                            self.lcm_ns_tasks[nsr_id][nslcmop_id]["delete_charm:" + application_name] = task
                 except Exception as e:
                     self.logger.debug(logging_text + "Failed while deleting charms: {}".format(e))
 
             # remove from RO
             RO_fail = False
             RO = ROclient.ROClient(self.loop, **self.ro_config)
+
             # Delete ns
-            if nsr_lcm and nsr_lcm.get("RO") and nsr_lcm["RO"].get("nsr_id"):
-                RO_nsr_id = nsr_lcm["RO"]["nsr_id"]
-                try:
+            RO_nsr_id = RO_delete_action = None
+            if nsr_lcm and nsr_lcm.get("RO"):
+                RO_nsr_id = nsr_lcm["RO"].get("nsr_id")
+                RO_delete_action = nsr_lcm["RO"].get("nsr_delete_action_id")
+            try:
+                if RO_nsr_id:
                     step = db_nsr_update["detailed-status"] = db_nslcmop_update["detailed-status"] = "Deleting ns at RO"
                     self.logger.debug(logging_text + step)
-                    await RO.delete("ns", RO_nsr_id)
+                    desc = await RO.delete("ns", RO_nsr_id)
+                    RO_delete_action = desc["action_id"]
+                    db_nsr_update["_admin.deployed.RO.nsr_delete_action_id"] = RO_delete_action
                     db_nsr_update["_admin.deployed.RO.nsr_id"] = None
                     db_nsr_update["_admin.deployed.RO.nsr_status"] = "DELETED"
-                except ROclient.ROClientException as e:
-                    if e.http_code == 404:  # not found
-                        db_nsr_update["_admin.deployed.RO.nsr_id"] = None
-                        db_nsr_update["_admin.deployed.RO.nsr_status"] = "DELETED"
-                        self.logger.debug(logging_text + "RO_ns_id={} already deleted".format(RO_nsr_id))
-                    elif e.http_code == 409:   # conflict
-                        failed_detail.append("RO_ns_id={} delete conflict: {}".format(RO_nsr_id, e))
-                        self.logger.debug(logging_text + failed_detail[-1])
-                        RO_fail = True
-                    else:
-                        failed_detail.append("RO_ns_id={} delete error: {}".format(RO_nsr_id, e))
-                        self.logger.error(logging_text + failed_detail[-1])
-                        RO_fail = True
+                if RO_delete_action:
+                    # wait until NS is deleted from VIM
+                    step = detailed_status = "Waiting ns deleted from VIM. RO_id={}".format(RO_nsr_id)
+                    detailed_status_old = None
+                    self.logger.debug(logging_text + step)
+
+                    delete_timeout = 20 * 60   # 20 minutes
+                    while delete_timeout > 0:
+                        desc = await RO.show("ns", item_id_name=RO_nsr_id, extra_item="action",
+                                             extra_item_id=RO_delete_action)
+                        ns_status, ns_status_info = RO.check_action_status(desc)
+                        if ns_status == "ERROR":
+                            raise ROclient.ROClientException(ns_status_info)
+                        elif ns_status == "BUILD":
+                            detailed_status = step + "; {}".format(ns_status_info)
+                        elif ns_status == "ACTIVE":
+                            break
+                        else:
+                            assert False, "ROclient.check_action_status returns unknown {}".format(ns_status)
+                        await asyncio.sleep(5, loop=self.loop)
+                        delete_timeout -= 5
+                        if detailed_status != detailed_status_old:
+                            detailed_status_old = db_nslcmop_update["detailed-status"] = detailed_status
+                            self.update_db_2("nslcmops", nslcmop_id, db_nslcmop_update)
+                    else:  # delete_timeout <= 0:
+                        raise ROclient.ROClientException("Timeout waiting ns deleted from VIM")
+
+            except ROclient.ROClientException as e:
+                if e.http_code == 404:  # not found
+                    db_nsr_update["_admin.deployed.RO.nsr_id"] = None
+                    db_nsr_update["_admin.deployed.RO.nsr_status"] = "DELETED"
+                    self.logger.debug(logging_text + "RO_ns_id={} already deleted".format(RO_nsr_id))
+                elif e.http_code == 409:   # conflict
+                    failed_detail.append("RO_ns_id={} delete conflict: {}".format(RO_nsr_id, e))
+                    self.logger.debug(logging_text + failed_detail[-1])
+                    RO_fail = True
+                else:
+                    failed_detail.append("RO_ns_id={} delete error: {}".format(RO_nsr_id, e))
+                    self.logger.error(logging_text + failed_detail[-1])
+                    RO_fail = True
 
             # Delete nsd
             if not RO_fail and nsr_lcm and nsr_lcm.get("RO") and nsr_lcm["RO"].get("nsd_id"):
@@ -1531,31 +1612,32 @@ class Lcm:
                 self.update_db_2("nslcmops", nslcmop_id, db_nslcmop_update)
                 self.update_db_2("nsrs", nsr_id, db_nsr_update)
                 await asyncio.wait(vca_task_list, timeout=300)
-            for vnf_index, task in vca_task_dict.items():
+            for application_name, task in vca_task_dict.items():
                 if task.cancelled():
-                    failed_detail.append("VCA[{}] Deletion has been cancelled".format(vnf_index))
+                    failed_detail.append("VCA[{}] Deletion has been cancelled".format(application_name))
                 elif task.done():
                     exc = task.exception()
                     if exc:
-                        failed_detail.append("VCA[{}] Deletion exception: {}".format(vnf_index, exc))
+                        failed_detail.append("VCA[{}] Deletion exception: {}".format(application_name, exc))
                     else:
-                        db_nsr_update["_admin.deployed.VCA.{}".format(vnf_index)] = None
+                        db_nsr_update["_admin.deployed.VCA.{}".format(application_name)] = None
                 else:  # timeout
                     # TODO Should it be cancelled?!!
                     task.cancel()
-                    failed_detail.append("VCA[{}] Deletion timeout".format(vnf_index))
+                    failed_detail.append("VCA[{}] Deletion timeout".format(application_name))
 
             if failed_detail:
                 self.logger.error(logging_text + " ;".join(failed_detail))
                 db_nsr_update["operational-status"] = "failed"
                 db_nsr_update["detailed-status"] = "Deletion errors " + "; ".join(failed_detail)
                 db_nslcmop_update["detailed-status"] = "; ".join(failed_detail)
-                db_nslcmop_update["operationState"] = "FAILED"
+                db_nslcmop_update["operationState"] = nslcmop_operation_state = "FAILED"
                 db_nslcmop_update["statusEnteredTime"] = time()
             elif db_nslcmop["operationParams"].get("autoremove"):
                 self.db.del_one("nsrs", {"_id": nsr_id})
                 db_nsr_update.clear()
                 self.db.del_list("nslcmops", {"nsInstanceId": nsr_id})
+                nslcmop_operation_state = "COMPLETED"
                 db_nslcmop_update.clear()
                 self.db.del_list("vnfrs", {"nsr-id-ref": nsr_id})
                 self.logger.debug(logging_text + "Delete from database")
@@ -1564,13 +1646,8 @@ class Lcm:
                 db_nsr_update["detailed-status"] = "Done"
                 db_nsr_update["_admin.nsState"] = "NOT_INSTANTIATED"
                 db_nslcmop_update["detailed-status"] = "Done"
-                db_nslcmop_update["operationState"] = "COMPLETED"
+                db_nslcmop_update["operationState"] = nslcmop_operation_state = "COMPLETED"
                 db_nslcmop_update["statusEnteredTime"] = time()
-            try:
-                await self.msg.aiowrite("ns", "terminated", {"nsr_id": nsr_id, "nslcmop_id": nslcmop_id})
-            except Exception as e:
-                self.logger.error(logging_text + "kafka_write notification Exception {}".format(e))
-            self.logger.debug(logging_text + "Exit")
 
         except (ROclient.ROClientException, DbException) as e:
             self.logger.error(logging_text + "Exit Exception {}".format(e))
@@ -1583,21 +1660,36 @@ class Lcm:
             self.logger.critical(logging_text + "Exit Exception {}".format(e), exc_info=True)
         finally:
             if exc and db_nslcmop:
-                db_nslcmop_update = {
-                    "detailed-status": "FAILED {}: {}".format(step, exc),
-                    "operationState": "FAILED",
-                    "statusEnteredTime": time(),
-                }
+                db_nslcmop_update["detailed-status"] = "FAILED {}: {}".format(step, exc)
+                db_nslcmop_update["operationState"] = nslcmop_operation_state = "FAILED"
+                db_nslcmop_update["statusEnteredTime"] = time()
             if db_nslcmop_update:
                 self.update_db_2("nslcmops", nslcmop_id, db_nslcmop_update)
             if db_nsr_update:
                 self.update_db_2("nsrs", nsr_id, db_nsr_update)
+            if nslcmop_operation_state:
+                try:
+                    await self.msg.aiowrite("ns", "terminated", {"nsr_id": nsr_id, "nslcmop_id": nslcmop_id,
+                                                                 "operationState": nslcmop_operation_state})
+                except Exception as e:
+                    self.logger.error(logging_text + "kafka_write notification Exception {}".format(e))
+            self.logger.debug(logging_text + "Exit")
             self.lcm_tasks.remove("ns", nsr_id, nslcmop_id, "ns_terminate")
 
-    async def _ns_execute_primitive(self, db_deployed, member_vnf_index, primitive, primitive_params):
-        vca_deployed = db_deployed["VCA"].get(member_vnf_index)
+    async def _ns_execute_primitive(self, db_deployed, nsr_name, member_vnf_index, vdu_id, primitive, primitive_params):
+
+        vdu_id_text = "vnfd"
+        if vdu_id:
+            vdu_id_text = vdu_id
+        application_name = self.n2vc.FormatApplicationName(
+            nsr_name,
+            member_vnf_index,
+            vdu_id_text
+        )
+        vca_deployed = db_deployed["VCA"].get(application_name)
         if not vca_deployed:
-            raise LcmException("charm for member_vnf_index={} is not deployed".format(member_vnf_index))
+            raise LcmException("charm for member_vnf_index={} vdu_id={} is not deployed".format(member_vnf_index,
+                                                                                                vdu_id))
         model_name = vca_deployed.get("model")
         application_name = vca_deployed.get("application")
         if not model_name or not application_name:
@@ -1647,24 +1739,26 @@ class Lcm:
         # get all needed from database
         db_nsr = None
         db_nslcmop = None
-        db_nslcmop_update = None
+        db_nslcmop_update = {}
+        nslcmop_operation_state = None
         exc = None
         try:
             step = "Getting information from database"
             db_nslcmop = self.db.get_one("nslcmops", {"_id": nslcmop_id})
             db_nsr = self.db.get_one("nsrs", {"_id": nsr_id})
             nsr_lcm = db_nsr["_admin"].get("deployed")
+            nsr_name = db_nsr["name"]
             vnf_index = db_nslcmop["operationParams"]["member_vnf_index"]
+            vdu_id = db_nslcmop["operationParams"].get("vdu_id")
 
             # TODO check if ns is in a proper status
             primitive = db_nslcmop["operationParams"]["primitive"]
             primitive_params = db_nslcmop["operationParams"]["primitive_params"]
-            result, result_detail = await self._ns_execute_primitive(nsr_lcm, vnf_index, primitive, primitive_params)
-            db_nslcmop_update = {
-                "detailed-status": result_detail,
-                "operationState": result,
-                "statusEnteredTime": time()
-            }
+            result, result_detail = await self._ns_execute_primitive(nsr_lcm, nsr_name, vnf_index, vdu_id, primitive,
+                                                                     primitive_params)
+            db_nslcmop_update["detailed-status"] = result_detail
+            db_nslcmop_update["operationState"] = nslcmop_operation_state = result
+            db_nslcmop_update["statusEnteredTime"] = time()
             self.logger.debug(logging_text + " task Done with result {} {}".format(result, result_detail))
             return  # database update is called inside finally
 
@@ -1679,13 +1773,19 @@ class Lcm:
             self.logger.critical(logging_text + "Exit Exception {} {}".format(type(e).__name__, e), exc_info=True)
         finally:
             if exc and db_nslcmop:
-                db_nslcmop_update = {
-                    "detailed-status": "FAILED {}: {}".format(step, exc),
-                    "operationState": "FAILED",
-                    "statusEnteredTime": time(),
-                }
+                db_nslcmop_update["detailed-status"] = "FAILED {}: {}".format(step, exc)
+                db_nslcmop_update["operationState"] = nslcmop_operation_state = "FAILED"
+                db_nslcmop_update["statusEnteredTime"] = time()
             if db_nslcmop_update:
                 self.update_db_2("nslcmops", nslcmop_id, db_nslcmop_update)
+            self.logger.debug(logging_text + "Exit")
+            if nslcmop_operation_state:
+                try:
+                    await self.msg.aiowrite("ns", "actioned", {"nsr_id": nsr_id, "nslcmop_id": nslcmop_id,
+                                                               "operationState": nslcmop_operation_state})
+                except Exception as e:
+                    self.logger.error(logging_text + "kafka_write notification Exception {}".format(e))
+            self.logger.debug(logging_text + "Exit")
             self.lcm_tasks.remove("ns", nsr_id, nslcmop_id, "ns_action")
 
     async def ns_scale(self, nsr_id, nslcmop_id):
@@ -1695,6 +1795,7 @@ class Lcm:
         db_nsr = None
         db_nslcmop = None
         db_nslcmop_update = {}
+        nslcmop_operation_state = None
         db_nsr_update = {}
         exc = None
         try:
@@ -1880,8 +1981,7 @@ class Lcm:
                     raise ROclient.ROClientException("Timeout waiting ns to be ready")
 
                 step = "Updating VNFRs"
-                # self.ns_update_vnfr({db_vnfr["member-vnf-index-ref"]: db_vnfr}, ns_RO_info)
-                self.ns_update_vnfr_2({db_vnfr["member-vnf-index-ref"]: db_vnfr}, desc)
+                self.ns_update_vnfr({db_vnfr["member-vnf-index-ref"]: db_vnfr}, desc)
 
                 # update VDU_SCALING_INFO with the obtained ip_addresses
                 if vdu_scaling_info["scaling_direction"] == "OUT":
@@ -1936,19 +2036,11 @@ class Lcm:
                         if result == "FAILED":
                             raise LcmException(result_detail)
 
-            db_nslcmop_update["operationState"] = "COMPLETED"
+            db_nslcmop_update["operationState"] = nslcmop_operation_state = "COMPLETED"
             db_nslcmop_update["statusEnteredTime"] = time()
             db_nslcmop_update["detailed-status"] = "done"
             db_nsr_update["detailed-status"] = "done"
             db_nsr_update["operational-status"] = "running"
-            try:
-                await self.msg.aiowrite("ns", "scaled", {"nsr_id": nsr_id, "nslcmop_id": nslcmop_id})
-                # if cooldown_time:
-                #     await asyncio.sleep(cooldown_time)
-                # await self.msg.aiowrite("ns", "scaled-cooldown-time", {"nsr_id": nsr_id, "nslcmop_id": nslcmop_id})
-            except Exception as e:
-                self.logger.error(logging_text + "kafka_write notification Exception {}".format(e))
-            self.logger.debug(logging_text + "Exit Ok")
             return
         except (ROclient.ROClientException, DbException, LcmException) as e:
             self.logger.error(logging_text + "Exit Exception {}".format(e))
@@ -1962,11 +2054,9 @@ class Lcm:
         finally:
             if exc:
                 if db_nslcmop:
-                    db_nslcmop_update = {
-                        "detailed-status": "FAILED {}: {}".format(step, exc),
-                        "operationState": "FAILED",
-                        "statusEnteredTime": time(),
-                    }
+                    db_nslcmop_update["detailed-status"] = "FAILED {}: {}".format(step, exc)
+                    db_nslcmop_update["operationState"] = nslcmop_operation_state = "FAILED"
+                    db_nslcmop_update["statusEnteredTime"] = time()
                 if db_nsr:
                     db_nsr_update["operational-status"] = "FAILED {}: {}".format(step, exc),
                     db_nsr_update["detailed-status"] = "failed"
@@ -1974,6 +2064,16 @@ class Lcm:
                 self.update_db_2("nslcmops", nslcmop_id, db_nslcmop_update)
             if db_nsr_update:
                 self.update_db_2("nsrs", nsr_id, db_nsr_update)
+            if nslcmop_operation_state:
+                try:
+                    await self.msg.aiowrite("ns", "scaled", {"nsr_id": nsr_id, "nslcmop_id": nslcmop_id,
+                                                             "operationState": nslcmop_operation_state})
+                    # if cooldown_time:
+                    #     await asyncio.sleep(cooldown_time)
+                    # await self.msg.aiowrite("ns","scaled-cooldown-time", {"nsr_id": nsr_id, "nslcmop_id": nslcmop_id})
+                except Exception as e:
+                    self.logger.error(logging_text + "kafka_write notification Exception {}".format(e))
+            self.logger.debug(logging_text + "Exit")
             self.lcm_tasks.remove("ns", nsr_id, nslcmop_id, "ns_scale")
 
     async def test(self, param=None):